Dudgeon v Marksmin WEEK 2: Appeal

[Banks]

Marksmin would like to appeal the dudgeon game.

Poni was supposed to be able to play today, Poni practiced w/ joeses all week thinking she was twl starter only to be told incorrectly by undercut she cant play.
This messed our line up going into the game, when the same day we were told Poni was not able to play, where NO WHERE in the rules it says that you must wait a week IF A PLAYER WAS PREVIOUSLY SQUADLESS.

Please fix, thank you.

[Banks]

Rule 4.04: The waiting period will be waived for a player that meets one of the following conditions: Have never been on the TWL roster for the current season.

Rule 11: If a squad feels that such factors as game referee decisions, staff involvement, server or router error, cheating, or other instances have affected the outcome and fairness of a game, that squad has the right to appeal to the League Operator.

Turban and undercut clearly had a missunderstanding with this rule.

[MHz]

when the same day we were told Poni was not able to play

Pretty sure you have to submit your roster before Saturday?

[PrOnEsSim]

Pretty sure you have to submit your roster before Saturday?

He was on the TWL roster spreadsheet, already.

[Tiny]

I support this appeal.

[Turban]

Undercut had misinformed the captains of Marksmin with a false statement saying Poni would not be eligible to play in their TWLB match. the sole purpose of this rule is to punish players who wish to change from one TWL squad to another during the season and is waived for players joining a league roster for the first time.

This misunderstanding is partly my fault as well for not double or triple checking the rules together with him. Sorry.

4.04 Waiting Period

The Standard Waiting Period for roster eligibility goes as follows: Any player joining a squad for participation in Trench Wars League (this includes changing names) after the last match of Round 1 will be subject to a one week Waiting Period after being added to the TWL roster by the Captain. After one week has elapsed they can play for their squad so long as they are not breaching the hard lock rules.

The waiting period will be waived for a player that meets one of the following conditions:

Have never been on the TWL roster for the current season.
Name change is due to their staff position.

as Poni has not been on any TWL roster for the current season, this appeal is granted and will be replayed on a later date.

[Falconeer]

Undercut had misinformed the captains of Marksmin with a false statement saying Poni would not be eligible to play in their TWLB match. the sole purpose of this rule is to punish players who wish to change from one TWL squad to another during the season and is waived for players joining a league roster for the first time.

This misunderstanding is partly my fault as well for not double or triple checking the rules together with him. Sorry.

4.04 Waiting Period

The Standard Waiting Period for roster eligibility goes as follows: Any player joining a squad for participation in Trench Wars League (this includes changing names) after the last match of Round 1 will be subject to a one week Waiting Period after being added to the TWL roster by the Captain. After one week has elapsed they can play for their squad so long as they are not breaching the hard lock rules.

The waiting period will be waived for a player that meets one of the following conditions:

Have never been on the TWL roster for the current season.
Name change is due to their staff position.

as Poni has not been on any TWL roster for the current season, this appeal is granted and will be replayed on a later date.

Quick LOCK the thread! :P