Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

TWDT 2016 Ratings

Collapse
X
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • #31
    Notes/Suggestions for next TWDT:


    1) Do ratings manually, and use these ratings as a baseline + next TWL performances. Crowdsourcing the ratings spreads out blame, but closed-session eye-test ratings are superior.

    2) Mix things up and go back to overall star-cap system. Either 38/38/61 or 37/37/60. Minimum 5-Star rating for each player.

    3) Keep draft packages, they're awesome.

    4) Reduce Free Agency to one, just before week 3. Ease had a valid complaint that the 2nd Week 5 draft completely changed the dynamic of the teams and punished successful teams and turned entire seasons around (ie, Silence picking up Diakka despite having an already strong roster -- they'd simply hadn't shown the first few weeks). This gives people 3 weeks to sign up, but they only miss 2, and maintains the integrity of the original draft. Week 5 was a bit too late.

    5) Free Agency Draft order should be determined as follows: Rate the captains 1-8 in how valuable they are since they dont have to draft themselves, then rate their draft positions 1-8 based on the field. A likely quality of original draft order would look like (1,2,3,8,7,4,5,6) -- Usually 1/2/3/7/8 are the best draft picks, and the middle ones 4/5/6 are the worst. Combine the two to see who has the biggest disadvantages and give them the best FA draft picks.

    6) Check for holidays and make sure they're accounted for in scheduling. Easter was a fuck up.

    7) Try to find a way around a bye week for Semi-Finals teams if possible (I can't think of a solution atm.)

    8) Let captains decide by vote on whether:

    a) Borrowing should be allowed during playoffs
    b) Whether Trades should be monitored for abuse or not. Darwinian free-for-all or nixing terrible trades and protecting newer/less experienced/dumber captains. I blocked 1-2 trades and there was an insane amount of non-stop crying, i.e. maketso, because I didn't allow him to take Mean Gene, a TWL starter who can jav/terr/spider at a high level, for Kentaro, who negged in wb and was drafted 40 picks later, from TJ Hazuki, who was a target all season (nanto for gurliver, mean gene for kentaro/paradise, etc.)


    That's about all I can think of right now.
    S18 TWLB Champ
    S19 TWLB Runner-Up
    S20 TWLD/TWLJ/TWLB Champ
    S21 TWLB Runner-Up
    S8/S9/S10 TWDT-D/TWDT-J/TWDT-B Champ
    S11 TWDT-B Runner-Up
    S12 TWDT-B Champ
    S13 TWDT-B Runner-Up
    S14 TWDT-B Champ
    S16 TWDT-B Runner-Up

    Comment


    • #32
      Originally posted by Claushouse View Post
      Notes/Suggestions for next TWDT:


      1) Do ratings manually, and use these ratings as a baseline + next TWL performances. Crowdsourcing the ratings spreads out blame, but closed-session eye-test ratings are superior.
      Updated for TWL performances. I'll do another pass with a group of people later. Crowdsourcing these to captains last year was a failure.

      Originally posted by Claushouse View Post
      2) Mix things up and go back to overall star-cap system. Either 38/38/61 or 37/37/60. Minimum 5-Star rating for each player.
      Leaning towards sticking with last year's system. Simpler, and more familiar.

      Originally posted by Claushouse View Post
      3) Keep draft packages, they're awesome.
      Yes!

      Originally posted by Claushouse View Post
      4) Reduce Free Agency to one, just before week 3. Ease had a valid complaint that the 2nd Week 5 draft completely changed the dynamic of the teams and punished successful teams and turned entire seasons around (ie, Silence picking up Diakka despite having an already strong roster -- they'd simply hadn't shown the first few weeks). This gives people 3 weeks to sign up, but they only miss 2, and maintains the integrity of the original draft. Week 5 was a bit too late.
      Done.

      Originally posted by Claushouse View Post
      5) Free Agency Draft order should be determined as follows: Rate the captains 1-8 in how valuable they are since they dont have to draft themselves, then rate their draft positions 1-8 based on the field. A likely quality of original draft order would look like (1,2,3,8,7,4,5,6) -- Usually 1/2/3/7/8 are the best draft picks, and the middle ones 4/5/6 are the worst. Combine the two to see who has the biggest disadvantages and give them the best FA draft picks.
      FA Draft order will be based on star level of captains to help player's who aren't as good.

      Originally posted by Claushouse View Post
      6) Check for holidays and make sure they're accounted for in scheduling. Easter was a fuck up.
      Season will finish before Easter. Valentine's Day falls on a Sunday, but it's the regular season, and the broom beam is passing off as his gf isn't fooling anyone.

      Originally posted by Claushouse View Post
      7) Try to find a way around a bye week for Semi-Finals teams if possible (I can't think of a solution atm.)
      404 Not Found

      Originally posted by Claushouse View Post
      8) Let captains decide by vote on whether:

      a) Borrowing should be allowed during playoffs
      b) Whether Trades should be monitored for abuse or not. Darwinian free-for-all or nixing terrible trades and protecting newer/less experienced/dumber captains. I blocked 1-2 trades and there was an insane amount of non-stop crying, i.e. maketso, because I didn't allow him to take Mean Gene, a TWL starter who can jav/terr/spider at a high level, for Kentaro, who negged in wb and was drafted 40 picks later, from TJ Hazuki, who was a target all season (nanto for gurliver, mean gene for kentaro/paradise, etc.)
      a) Making an executive decision on the first one, borrowing will be allowed during playoffs.

      b) Relinquishing power of evaluating trades and giving it to caps -- TWDT Ops will no longer be involved.
      S18 TWLB Champ
      S19 TWLB Runner-Up
      S20 TWLD/TWLJ/TWLB Champ
      S21 TWLB Runner-Up
      S8/S9/S10 TWDT-D/TWDT-J/TWDT-B Champ
      S11 TWDT-B Runner-Up
      S12 TWDT-B Champ
      S13 TWDT-B Runner-Up
      S14 TWDT-B Champ
      S16 TWDT-B Runner-Up

      Comment


      • #33
        Ardour - 7

        Neymar - 8



        This the biggest injustice since Steven Avery!!!

        I am Neymar. Please adjust my jav value to 8 please.

        Much love
        xox
        TWLD Season 19 #70th Best Warbird
        TWLB Season 19 #56th Best Spider

        TW Greatest no-shipper 2002 - Present

        Public 2011 - Achievements:
        - Basing King : Ardour (+$320)
        - Most Veteran Like : Ardour (+$160)
        - Flag Savior : Ardour (+$160)
        - Best Terrier : Ardour (+$160)
        - Most Terrier Kills : Ardour (+$60)

        Cross> rozis r red n artirs r blue. i luv reindirs n artir is one 2
        1:Trasher> ardour is better than tiny

        Comment


        • #34
          Originally posted by Ardour View Post
          Ardour - 7

          Neymar - 8



          This the biggest injustice since Steven Avery!!!

          I am Neymar. Please adjust my jav value to 8 please.

          Much love
          xox
          Lol, looks like you sandbag on Neymar :>
          ♪♫♪♫♪♫♪♫♪♫♪♫
          Failure teaches success.
          .
          

          Comment


          • #35
            Originally posted by Kim View Post
            Lol, looks like you sandbag on Neymar :>

            Was Rope-a-dopeing all opponents... so sad I couldn't show for the Juans match....
            Cobra TWLJ champs Season 21.
            TWLD Season 19 #70th Best Warbird
            TWLB Season 19 #56th Best Spider

            TW Greatest no-shipper 2002 - Present

            Public 2011 - Achievements:
            - Basing King : Ardour (+$320)
            - Most Veteran Like : Ardour (+$160)
            - Flag Savior : Ardour (+$160)
            - Best Terrier : Ardour (+$160)
            - Most Terrier Kills : Ardour (+$60)

            Cross> rozis r red n artirs r blue. i luv reindirs n artir is one 2
            1:Trasher> ardour is better than tiny

            Comment

            Working...
            X