TWDD TWJD MVP system

[Foreign]

unless we keep bumping it til someone else does something about it ^_^

[Vykromond]

foreign's formula works to the max

put it in

[lecherious young gun]

This thread is moronic, there will never be a formula to figure out a real mvp. I mean most kills is a just that most kills, in any game any situation you are going to have a most valueable player lets take a dd where you are losing and someone gets subbed in late and gets 6-0 and turns the whole game around and you win? What then etc... The current system is flawed in that in a game someone who is 15:10 will get mvp rather than someone 13:2 but no matter what you change it to a system that relies on formulas is not going to be a good gauge.

[Awesome]

serious deductions need to be made on the formula for actually being eliminated i think

getting to 10 deaths (or however many you are left with when subbed in) is horrible to your team because the man advantage is a huge part of the game.

i dunno, just never liked the idea that someone who gets eliminated gets the MVP award. unless they get like 22 kills or something, but still, being eliminated doesn't help your team. the survivor(s) are the ones who win the game.

[InCure.]

You're drivign me nuts with all those formules

[Foreign]

One thing that could be implemented is # of clutch kills.

so you would add this number to the existing formula:

KILLS*(KILLS-DEATHS)*(PLAYTIME/TOTALTIME)
+
KILLS*(KILLS-DEATHS)*(PLAYTIME/TOTALTIME)*((clutchKills+1)/numOpponents)

5v5
so 20-10 after half a game with 1 clutch gets 100 + 40 = 140
a 10-0 with 0 clutch gets a 100 + 20 = 120
a 16-8 with 2 clutch gets a 128 + 76.8 = 204.8
a 14-8 with 4 clutch gets a 84 + 100.8 = 184.8

[Randedl]

i agree with foreign.

[tahkis]

Is the MVP this important?

[Foreign]

Is the MVP this important?

depends on how often you get shafted.

[Fit of Rage]

Hahaha you said shafted.

I also like foreign's idea. Now how are we going to fix the TWBD mvp?

[ogron]

I think MVP is important enough. It's fun being recognized for you efforts, just like it's fun to win a game.

Obviously winning takes precedence, but identifying the best player of the match is also relatively important.

Of course, if youre going to do it, do it right

[Toasty]

Winning is enough mvp isnt that important...lets say team (A) wins while they all get 8-7 or something like that but team (B) loses but one guy on their team gets like 20-10 they lost, is mvp important then?

[Izor]

ill mvp whatever dd i play in, so it doesnt really make a difference

[Dameon Angell]

Here.... equasion time.

MVP = player with most points.

ez.

[Foreign]

Winning is enough mvp isnt that important...lets say team (A) wins while they all get 8-7 or something like that but team (B) loses but one guy on their team gets like 20-10 they lost, is mvp important then?

the point is not whether it is important. If you'd like to talk about that, this is not the thread This thread is for ideas about the EXISTING MVP system for JD/LD.

And, it would be antithetical to the very fabric of subspace team play for Trench Wars to separate its leagues from all others by removing the MVP award. While I see your point, we're dealing with something that isn't ever likely to be removed. Since that is the case, it is best to make MVP as fairly measured as possible. Wouldn't you agree?