Should TWSD just become TWFD?

[Marduke]

Well this idea could be considered in the future, or for a near future hosted event.

Have maximum of 2 warbirds, and the rest could be any combo of spiders and lancasters out of 3 remaining ship slots.

Have a fighter ship duel tournyment (5vs5)

Depending who shows up, have maybe 4-6 twdd maps, so you could handle 40-60 people.

Have a map similiar to the twdd map, but have multiple twdd maps ganged up on the big map.

It would be a good way to test it out and plus it would be a good change and for fun.

[Kuukunen]

Ok, this is not the same thing I said. You put some poorly constructed sentance down that while it did suggest there was something vaguely incorrect about his post, it didnt tell us what was wrong with it.

I just let the reader do the math, and it certainly was not a flame. I'll give you a hint. His claim: Wbs are superiors to spiders in ev every way. Fact: spid lineup will over power wb lineup in base easily.
I think that fact will pretty much make his original claim void. And you just quoted the first post about it.

You put some poorly constructed sentance down

sentence*

[VladTaltos]

Lol

[Kolar]

In open space warbirds are superior to spiders.

[Kuukunen]

In open space warbirds are superior to spiders.

Yep, but was there anyone who claimed otherwise? Vlad, were you talking about open space?

[Kolar]

I thought you and him were in dispute about that Kuuk.

[Troll King]

I think they were arguing over whether one agreed with the other or if it was the other way around.

[Kuukunen]

Ok, so in case it was unclear to anyone, let's have a history lesson. Long long time ago TWLD (That's Trench Wars League Dueling) was all ship thing. But people noticed quickly wb was the best ship to do stuff in open space. I doubt they didn't try different line ups.

Actually it might very well be possible that wbs own spids in closed space dueling too. Wbs are faster, so they can just run away and if spids chase, snipe them around the corner. If the spids don't chase, snipe them long distance. If you think the spids could drive the wbs in a corner, you have no idea of how hard it is to kill a full energy wb with a spid when he tries to run. If the area was closed enough (sized like base in belim.) then spids might have an advantage. But I don't know, I think it hasn't really been properly tested.

If you pro-spids don't believe me on wb owning spid, look me up and I'll show you what I mean.

[Kuukunen]

I think they were arguing over whether one agreed with the other or if it was the other way around.

Well I was just pointing out errors and illogicalities in his post.

[VladTaltos]

In a closed space, it isnt that hard to corner and kill a full energy WB with a Spid. This being said, no one ever said that this division would have to be played on an open space map. I like the idea of involving a bunch of ships, but without it just being basing. So ya, maybe some map adjustments would have to be made to level the playing field, but there is no reason something like that could be done. All I was trying to say by posting here in the first place is that, while it is ok to disagree with an idea, just say something simple. Don't be an ass. If you agree, post something constructive. I tried, obviously that didn't go over well with you guys, so I apoligize.

[Kuukunen]

Nah, people just disagreed. If the map is not full of dead ends, wb can easily run from spids without getting cornered and the map would not be full of dead ends.