blacklisting

[Nimrook]

another cheaters thread again? sigh

[RaCka]

hi

[Izor]

another cheaters thread again? sigh

didnt intend for this to be about cheaters, just what were going to do when theyre caught

[Doc Flabby]

You're new, so you can make up for it. But as of now, I'll label you as a complete moron to think Shinobi cheats.

I didnt say all of shinobi cheats. But there were players i thought who cheat in shinobi. I havnt see shinobi play for a while (over 2 months) to im happy to take that off that list as serveral people say they dont, unless anyone objects.

The only way this whitelist thing to work is if get feedback from multiple sources and games. As one game might just be laggy and i got i wrong - but if lots of people say a squad eats or uses alias'd people and shit like that we know to advoid them.


Squads that cheat
------------------

golden
Indorse
With Honor
Ownage

Squads that don't cheat - laggy but ok
-----------------------
$flabby$
Shinobi
wingmasters
ancients
-eNyCE-

Squads that don't cheat - low lag (on average)
-----------------------
sk8
disoblige
passion


Any changes reply to this thread.

[Deluge]

doc flabby always lists about 6 squads i never heard of

[pascone]

I didnt say all of shinobi cheats. But there were players i thought who cheat in shinobi. I havnt see shinobi play for a while (over 2 months) to im happy to take that off that list as serveral people say they dont, unless anyone objects.

The only way this whitelist thing to work is if get feedback from multiple sources and games. As one game might just be laggy and i got i wrong - but if lots of people say a squad eats or uses alias'd people and shit like that we know to advoid them.



Squads that don't cheat - low lag (on average)
-----------------------
sk8
disoblige
passion


Any changes reply to this thread.

??????????????????????????????? sk8 and diso have to be 2 of the laggiest squads

[kthx]

Hmm this is an interesting Idea. First off if we are going to have a captains meeting at a certain time this week, lets try to get an upper staff member who can make changes there with us, to listen to our concerns and see our answers. Perhaps Rudy or PL would be able to make it to this, would really help, and maybe an active TWL op also, such as Dameon or M_M god. There are a few problems we are going to face though. I think a little more openness from staff and captains of squads who are obviously planning on being in TWL this year is needed. If X player asks to join my squad, and I don't really know him that well, but see him play in so and so and he plays a good style. I should be able to ask a mod if this player is legit, or if he is currently on another squad, or has had an alt banned for cheating, lag inducing etc etc. I think staff could also do alot more if they had captains talking to them about who wants to join, perhaps stop certain instances of double squadding and or other problems before they even arise. Also, we need a list of players possibly from staff, who are even suspected of cheating, I know that is probaly kept very private but, it would really help. My thought is, if you even suspect a certain player of cheating, I don't want that sort of attention to my squad, and would probaly blacklist them. Anyways, comment back on these ideas.


- Kthx Co-Captain of Quicksand.

[Doc Flabby]

doc flabby always lists about 6 squads i never heard of

and you've listed none gg, i play in euro timezone i dont see half the squads play.

??????????????????????????????? sk8 and diso have to be 2 of the laggiest squads

When i've played them they die when hit therefore in not laggy category :P

but if anyone else wants to agree with pascone ill move them.

Im not really the best person to be making this list but as no one else is doing it :P

[Dameon Angell]

Hmm this is an interesting Idea. First off if we are going to have a captains meeting at a certain time this week, lets try to get an upper staff member who can make changes there with us, to listen to our concerns and see our answers. Perhaps Rudy or PL would be able to make it to this, would really help, and maybe an active TWL op also, such as Dameon or M_M god. There are a few problems we are going to face though. I think a little more openness from staff and captains of squads who are obviously planning on being in TWL this year is needed. If X player asks to join my squad, and I don't really know him that well, but see him play in so and so and he plays a good style. I should be able to ask a mod if this player is legit, or if he is currently on another squad, or has had an alt banned for cheating, lag inducing etc etc. I think staff could also do alot more if they had captains talking to them about who wants to join, perhaps stop certain instances of double squadding and or other problems before they even arise. Also, we need a list of players possibly from staff, who are even suspected of cheating, I know that is probaly kept very private but, it would really help. My thought is, if you even suspect a certain player of cheating, I don't want that sort of attention to my squad, and would probaly blacklist them. Anyways, comment back on these ideas.


- Kthx Co-Captain of Quicksand.

Like I said, lets do this tomorrow, I have the day off of work, and I have a fucking cold like hell, so I won't be going anywhere. Tomorrow night, I'll be on in ?go AngellBase, lets setup shop there. No later than 8:00 pm PST. We can move to a private arena when we get ready. Any squad captains not there will not be apart of the founding group of the Squad Alliance and will have no vote in later elections.

[Ward]

no1 would play your squad then

thx, thats what i thought too

[Dameon Angell]

Actually, cross that, lets do this next week, more time to plan it. I can set some guidelines and etc*

[a2m+]

If this happens, your expecting people to be mature and thoughtful when deciding who to blacklist... This is impossible. I garauntee dice is a squadname that gets thrown out there by someone or another for being blacklisted despite the fact that we DONT cheat. I admit that there are definately more people cheating in tw than there should be, but people are blaming EVERYTHING on CE and throwing around accusations left and right like you can buy them at the 99 cent store.

[Doc Flabby]

If this happens, your expecting people to be mature and thoughtful when deciding who to blacklist... This is impossible. I garauntee dice is a squadname that gets thrown out there by someone or another for being blacklisted despite the fact that we DONT cheat. I admit that there are definately more people cheating in tw than there should be, but people are blaming EVERYTHING on CE and throwing around accusations left and right like you can buy them at the 99 cent store.

I think black listing should not just be based on the judgement of one squad. My opinion of shiobi was dat they cheat but alot of people say otherwise so majority view would indicate the truth, and that i am wrong. If a simular system was used with blacklisting i should think dice would be safe.

[Dameon Angell]

it'll be majority rule and common sense. trust me we're not gonna blacklist dice or other
respectable squads.

[Nimrook]

same question as the other thread.. who is this year's TWL coordinator?