TWDT 2017 Player Ratings -- PUBLIC COMMENT PERIOD

[Jessup]

please make me 65 rating in all ships , thanks

[skyforger]

remove -10 accross the board pls. no way im meaningfully better than a vet like henry saari.

[skyforger]

also activity rating a complete sham as well. i login only for leagues

compare skyforger vs ogron


tsl s2

activity rating 10 vs 7

tslb 11 games vs ogron's 14
tslj 16 vs 13
tsld 10 vs 22

lol.

[Ricko]

yeah I'm somehow an 8 in activity, whereas Ogron has 7....however I've played 20 games in TSL so far this season vs Ogron's 49. This will prob drop my rating!

[skyforger]

ratings don't need to be a subjective effort of 1 (or 5) guys, when we got math. lemme explain.

nearly everyone played tsl. calculate tsl average $ per game of all players who have played atleast 20 tsl games . say iron survivor is the best average $ with 25$/game avg, racka is 2nd best with 24$ avg. iron survivor is 10.0 as the best. racka a 9.6. (24$ is 96% of 25$) and so on for everyone.

for those select few that have not played a good sample of tsl in the 2 seasons, have the panel of 5 review them. with a much lesser amount of players to evaluate manually its more likely the panel can do more in-depth research.

if activity needs to be calculated, same deal - use tsl activity with the same trickle down system. no bias.

its less drama, quicker and more likely to be accurate, like pretty sure math wont support skyfroger have a higher total than ogron, geio, lasenza, thix etc.

[kess]

ratings don't need to be a subjective effort of 1 (or 5) guys, when we got math. lemme explain.

nearly everyone played tsl. calculate tsl average $ per game of all players who have played atleast 20 tsl games . say iron survivor is the best average $ with 25$/game avg, racka is 2nd best with 24$ avg. iron survivor is 10.0 as the best. racka a 9.6. (24$ is 96% of 25$) and so on for everyone.

for those select few that have not played a good sample of tsl in the 2 seasons, have the panel of 5 review them. with a much lesser amount of players to evaluate manually its more likely the panel can do more in-depth research.

if activity needs to be calculated, same deal - use tsl activity with the same trickle down system. no bias.

its less drama, quicker and more likely to be accurate, like pretty sure math wont support skyfroger have a higher total than ogron, geio, lasenza, thix etc.

Tsl is definetly the way to go when evaluating activity. But as far as skill goes, TSL is far from being a correct representation. I rather have some veterans reviewing the ratings than using TSL values.

[Tiny]

Tsl is definetly the way to go when evaluating activity. But as far as skill goes, TSL is far from being a correct representation. I rather have some veterans reviewing the ratings than using TSL values.

Agreed, I believe there are some who don't try 100% every round or are unrusting in tsl, that will greatly skew their rating when they start really practicing and playing twdt.

[ogron]

I received an email with jav ratings from an email that wasn't signed. I'm parsing the ratings for clues, but nothing has turned up yet.

It's a mystery, I guess :huh2:


https://gyazo.com/5ec266cdbecbec8524f78eb7ceda21ed

[Ricko]

I received an email with jav ratings from an email that wasn't signed. I'm parsing the ratings for clues, but nothing has turned up yet.

It's a mystery, I guess :huh2:


https://gyazo.com/5ec266cdbecbec8524f78eb7ceda21ed

:laugh::laugh::laugh:

[kess]

Agreed, I believe there are some who don't try 100% every round or are unrusting in tsl, that will greatly skew their rating when they start really practicing and playing twdt.

Add to that, the complete bs lineups that sometimes u have to face. There is a clear misjudgement on some players(impossible to get it 100% right) and you see mid tier players completely making games unfair due to severely outpeforming their counterparts

[Wirah]

I'm listed twice in that spreadsheet

[Smoking Blue]

why am i a 7 in jav? its the worst league and apart from hating JD, i almost never play it or care about it. Lets not forget i havent even played tw in a year. Learn to make proper ratings please. If i should get a 7 in an league it should be WB as its the onl one ive earned a medal on and ive beaten some high star warbirds in duel, soem aliased some on their main. 7 in base? lol so a guy who doesnt even play tw is on par with the majority of the zone. says alot about how crap this zone really is.