Trading Thread

[Majorcrisis2]

Seems like that solves Racka's problems but doesn't solve Pressure's problems. I'd still approve it tho.

How can u approve that?
Willby = rodney
Lockdown is better wb than jack rest is kinda equal imo, but then skyforger better in general than raji. So that evens it out. There is nothing that evens out 24, especially his jav.

And lets not talk about the rounds both sides got picked.

[Rab]

Seems like that solves Racka's problems but doesn't solve Pressure's problems. I'd still approve it tho.

[Pressure]

Blast offers Rodney / Jack / 24 / Skyforger to Slay for Lockdown / Willby / Raiji

Accepted.

[RaCka]

Blast offers Rodney / Jack / 24 / Skyforger to Slay for Lockdown / Willby / Raiji

[Tiny]

The votes were made by lockdown heaven and willby. If there's ever a tie, it would go to wirah/qan for a tiebreak.

And this guy made fun of me being involved in rating stuff. LOL

[viop11]

lool imigine qan votink on a trade i dun think i haf efir seen her play a mitch/entir cintinim

[beam]

The votes were made by lockdown heaven and willby. If there's ever a tie, it would go to wirah/qan for a tiebreak.

[LaG KiLLeR]

This trade was voted on by a committee that I selected prior to the season and passed 2-1. I did abstain from voting for the reasons you mentioned.

Great to hear that you abstained. It's also important for everyone to know who the 4 person committee is. You, Willby, Wirah &?

It's great to know you abstained from the voting process. Kudos on that.

And I agree with River that it's important to disclose which individuals make up the voting committee. Personally, I think it'd be most fair to include one representative per team so each team has an equal voice on the decision (but what you currently have is better than nothing).

[Riverside]

This trade was voted on by a committee that I selected prior to the season and passed 2-1. I did abstain from voting for the reasons you mentioned.

Great to hear that you abstained. It's also important for everyone to know who the 4 person committee is. You, Willby, Wirah &?

[beam]

To be honest, you shouldn't have executive decision over this trade as there's a clear conflict of interest (you're on one [Powers] of the squads involved in the trade).

Although maybe too late for this season, I'd recommend creating a committee (unbiased individuals or a representative per team) next season in which majority vote determines the trade outcome and members of a team involved in the trade have no say. Additionally, require captains to submit a brief write-up on the forums (provides full transparency for all TWDT players) justifying why they want to make the trade, etc. Although not perfect, it'd make the trading process a little more fair for all involved. Just something to consider anyway.

This trade was voted on by a committee that I selected prior to the season and passed 2-1. I did abstain from voting for the reasons you mentioned.

[LaG KiLLeR]

Approved. While this trade doesn't seem to be perfectly even, it's not egregiously bad enough for me to veto it. Violence is confident this will improve his team and I trust his leadership enough to believe that he has a plan.

To be honest, you shouldn't have executive decision over this trade as there's a clear conflict of interest (you're on one [Powers] of the squads involved in the trade).

Although maybe too late for this season, I'd recommend creating a committee (unbiased individuals or a representative per team) next season in which majority vote determines the trade outcome and members of a team involved in the trade have no say. Additionally, require captains to submit a brief write-up on the forums (provides full transparency for all TWDT players) justifying why they want to make the trade, etc. Although not perfect, it'd make the trading process a little more fair for all involved. Just something to consider anyway.

[beam]

mastirs trades kado to power for mean gene

Approved. While this trade doesn't seem to be perfectly even, it's not egregiously bad enough for me to veto it. Violence is confident this will improve his team and I trust his leadership enough to believe that he has a plan.

[viop11]

dreamwin wudnt trade me ardour 4 kado so shows u how gud she thinks kado is. Genir is a gr8 value in all leagues at 7/8.5/8.5 and am happy 2 haf her. we played understarred last weekend in all leagues because we were missing vys, creature, kado, and kira. if we wud haf had genir with us am 90000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000% sure we wud haf went 6-0 0 effirt. furthirmore u cud argue kado is overvalued at 9* spidirmin, howefir she is a gr8 jiflin, but i think we cud still fuk ne1 with genir who cud b just as gud or bettir

[Heaven]

regarding activity, kado stated he wouldn't show the 1st two weeks and would be there the rest.

[Tiny]

I got nothing against kado, but he does seem to be a liability in TWDT whereas mene gene shows a bunch and is easier to fit in lineups, like someone else already said. Maybe throw in a low star player to make everyone happy? i mean, 3rd round for a 5th round player is not terrible, considering the 3rd round player doesnt show up much, makes it pretty even.