TWDT25 Player Ratings

[Dwopple]

Link to ratings sheet

Ratings are about 75% complete so far.

We're doing an average by comittee. Generally speaking, player ratings will be rounded to the nearest .5 number using standard rounding rules. There are a handful of instances where a player is not rated, or we are waiting one someone to finish rating a specific league (jav). Ratings will be fluid up until the time of the player draft.

Sign up for TWDT
Draft Order

[Riverside]

Holy barnicils this looks like a lot 2 have done in 1 sitting, even split between divisins.

I appreciate it 2 the ppl who haf done so:

Ricki, Zid, Ogrin, Dwippil

My feedback, which is relative to the existing list of players, and based on:

• Recent TWDT play (ie Playoffs where a playir is a victir, Regular Seasin as well)
• What i remember seeing from playing vs them overall
• Noticing a difference in an individuals ratings from last season to this seasons at times: improvements in skill & an increase in ratings happen, esp since Summer League has 105+ players (!!!) so far, vs last season
• Avoiding more than a +.5 increase (arbirtiry margin of error in this sitiation)

GenX (wb): 7 -> 7.5
GenX (basing: spidir): 8.5 -> 9
monkee (wb): 7 -> 7.5
Groan (basing: spidir): 7.5 -> 8
Vehicle (basing: shark): 8 -> 8.5
Mean Gene (jav): 8.5 -> 9
Mean Gene (basing: spidir) 8.5 -> 9
Frozen Throne (wb): 7-> 7.5
Stek (wb): 6.5 -> 7
Clefairy (basing: spidir): 8-> 8.5
Lee (basing: spidir): 7-> 7.5


H
Y
P
E

[Dwopple]

Updated link to direct to the excel version. Fairly certain if you sort it currently the ratings may not sort with it due to the VLOOKUPS I'm using. Out on a boat fishing until this afternoon so I will make it sortable when I get back.

[Dwopple]

Updated the ratings sheet to be sortable, and sorted by highest overall * rating.

[Exalt]

Are there any notable changes in this rating sheet? After a quick scan, I didn't see anyone higher/lower from the previous season. It's fine to keep them as they were, but if there are changes, wouldn't it be easier to just list those instead of everyone who stayed the same?

Edit: Are the changes just the people who were previously unrated?

I suggest a couple of people I noticed should likely be changed slightly, at least in WB. Maybe Racka can take a look at this. Just my opinions from playing a lot lately and seeing these guys daily:

Killah should probably be 6.5 in WB, since he hasn't played in 15 years and is on par or worse than the other 6.5s right now. He will likely improve as he unrusts, but that will probably take longer than the TWDT season to accomplish.

I think Sunny D is a 7.5 WB right now. He's in that spot where he can put up big numbers or can go 5-10 at any time, which seems to be a 7.5 rating based on everyone else at this number?

Ravage is better than 6.5 in Jav, especially since I'm a 7 and I'm awful. At the very least, he's as good as guys who are also 7.5 like Riverside, Mongrel, etc in jav.

Zapata is not a 8.5 WB right now.

Monkee is probably a 7.5 WB. He's play is too high-IQ to be a 7 IMO, which is where Pawner is rated.

Riverside is not an 8.5 WB right now.

Warrior is not an 8 WB right now.

Jz probably deserves a bump up to 8+. https://twd.trenchwars.org/?v=profil...ent&leagueID=4 Look at these stats in TWDD and tell me how he's still a 7.5.


There are more but this is just a quick rundown. Some of these guys can be adjusted slightly for their current activity and ability levels based on that. Otherwise, they might not see play or might be too big of a steal. I know I'd take Monkee at a 7* WB all day everyday for instance. That just seems too low for a smart player. JZ is too low as well for a guy that guarantees you 10+ and teamwork no matter what.

[RageRitual]

Riverside My spider has not improved at all, I have always been better at spider than the other two basing ships. The zone is usually short on Sharks or Terriers so I end up having to play them instead.

[LeeRomeno]

Holy barnicils this looks like a lot 2 have done in 1 sitting, even split between divisins.

I appreciate it 2 the ppl who haf done so:

Ricki, Zid, Ogrin, Dwippil

My feedback, which is relative to the existing list of players, and based on:

• Recent TWDT play (ie Playoffs where a playir is a victir, Regular Seasin as well)
• What i remember seeing from playing vs them overall
• Noticing a difference in an individuals ratings from last season to this seasons at times: improvements in skill & an increase in ratings happen, esp since Summer League has 105+ players (!!!) so far, vs last season
• Avoiding more than a +.5 increase (arbirtiry margin of error in this sitiation)

GenX (wb): 7 -> 7.5
GenX (basing: spidir): 8.5 -> 9
monkee (wb): 7 -> 7.5
Groan (basing: spidir): 7.5 -> 8
Vehicle (basing: shark): 8 -> 8.5
Mean Gene (jav): 8.5 -> 9
Mean Gene (basing: spidir) 8.5 -> 9
Frozen Throne (wb): 7-> 7.5
Stek (wb): 6.5 -> 7
Clefairy (basing: spidir): 8-> 8.5
Lee (basing: spidir): 7-> 7.5


H
Y
P
E

I have not played a single bd since last league (as they never happen at euro timezone), so i highly doubt my level has increased in any way.