TW Mafia: Still Worthy

[Voth]

Unofficial Current Vote Count:

Jessup - The_Paul, Kthx, Exalt, Voth
Ixt - Halp, Missa
Halp - Backwards, Ixt
The_Paul - Field
Fis - Rodney

Yet to vote:

Fis
Jessup

Hammer vote at 7 votes


After getting together the vote count and re reading through the thread

Vote Fis

Reading over the thread and checking out where the votes are and how they formed i noticed FiS has posted not more than 1 sentence in any post she has submitted. None of it has contributed anything to help scum hunt or prosecute. All the posts containing useless words like this








No conclusive opinion or thought, looks scummy

I do agree that Fis' sudden change of vote off of Jessup without any reason other than "I don't think she is a good candidate for lynching today" was suspicious. Also, the indecisiveness and say-nothingness of her posts is a good point that I didn't catch until you brought it up. Classic scum play to constantly remind everyone how much you don't know and how much you don't suspect to avoid your name being thrown around because you're actively scumhunting.

Is it possible that Fis was just masquerading a vote on Jessup in a necessary tilt of her hat to their perpetual feud? And perhaps it is a convenient lull in this day phase where she can go ahead and remove her vote on Jessup in hopes to keep her around? As has been said multiple times, town Jessup is as much a member of the scum team as any scum. She is literally brain damaged.

Very interesting catch Rodney. Very interesting indeed. Fis, anything of substance to say? Why did you unvote Jessup...specifically?

[kthx]

Yeah that fis unvote looks scummy as fuck, not enough t ok change my vote though.

[ixt]

id like to hear from field again, i cant imagine his first vote on paul was even close to 50% serious, would like to hear what he has to say after more recent development

[RoDNeY]

Unofficial Current Vote Count:

Jessup - The_Paul, Kthx, Exalt, Voth
Ixt - Halp, Missa
Halp - Backwards, Ixt
The_Paul - Field
Fis - Rodney

Yet to vote:

Fis
Jessup

Hammer vote at 7 votes


After getting together the vote count and re reading through the thread

Vote Fis

Reading over the thread and checking out where the votes are and how they formed i noticed FiS has posted not more than 1 sentence in any post she has submitted. None of it has contributed anything to help scum hunt or prosecute. All the posts containing useless words like this

I have no idea where to look though, with all that off topic talk and Jessup train I have no reads.

I don't mind voting either ixt or Jessup.

I will try to look at this game again later today with more detail and try to find leads. However, rationally Jessup appears to be a bad candidate for lynch today.

No conclusive opinion or thought, looks scummy

[sdrawkcab]

Yes, I am outside the main group.. I think jessup is just being jessup and I do not want to be part of this jessup discussion as I have nothing to add to it... I think this is what a scum jessup would look like... I think this is what a town jessup would look like... so I won?t defend her but I?m not going to try to lynch her either. Fis does make a point that a late game town aligned jessup could prove to be a liability but lynching her for that will just start giving us one less person signing up...

i agree with T_P that any role or name claiming here on D1 is a bad idea and I?m watching who?s trying to systematically get people to give out info

also, posting on my phone drives me insane with the question marks

[ixt]

(edit 265) *series of troll posting

[ixt]

to clarify what i mean, i mean making moves on people when not even everyone has piped up yet

[ixt]

in all seriousness stopping to think about it, ill probably consider gripe temporarily at the moment. With how the game has developed, he was the first to use the phrase "scumpost" even through extremely limited clues while not everyone has spoken up. Both him and backwards are giving me this "outside the main group of development,, melting in the shadows" kind of vibe, so at this moment hazarding a guess at least one of the two could be mafia. also, after a serious of troll posting, kthx seemed to have temporarily disappear?

unvote missa
vote halp

[Exalt]

Fuck it, I'm just gonna claim. I'm the Purple Power Ranger, Day Ninja Forensics Investigator. I day investigated exalt ninja stylez and he's got locomotive grease on his hands. Choo Choo motherfucker.

If there's anything I've learned playing TW mafia, it is that quality of logic cannot be used as a measurement to determine scumminess. I'd put money on exalt being scum right now, in any conventional reality, but not here. Here he's just a 30 year old teenager who loves reading his own arguments so much he doesn't bother thinking about how much sense they actually make.

Don't worry friend, I will be coming to lynch your scummy ass soon enough too. The squeaky wheel gets the grease, but after Jessup, you're the next biggest problem to solve. You can claim my arguments are bad, yet you've done nothing to actually show how they are bad. Actually, based on your argument, I should be town, since you claim my arguments aren't logical (and thus are scummy) in the same sentence that you claim logic can't be used to measure scumminess in TW Mafia. If I'm a 30 year old teenager, then I'm the valevictorian of this school, while you're the creepy neckbeard kid that eats his boogers and doesn't know what deodorant and soap are.

[Exalt]

I'm not claiming tonight. We have 24 more hours and I need 2 votes still. I may claim tomorrow all depending in morning, Obvious reasons not to role reveal are that Towns game chances could be hurt and offenive info can be leaked to scum in process which will again hurt towns chances..

I'd love to see if

Valkyrie would claim town too as she is in the narrative

with me. Someone out here is her. 99% sure. She could be the key to proving I am town.

The closest I can get now is admitting I have the same situation zeebu had in the tolkswagon game. The narrative on page 1 is about me., page 1 , post #3 is about me and it confirms that town is fighting

the enemies of Asgard and we are fighting Chitauri in particular.

Also that the hammer has been destroyed.

Jessup, all you've been doing is repeating the narrative mod post from page 1 and calling that information. No, it's not. It's bullshit, and you know it. Beyond that, my role doesn't say a damn thing about chitauri or mjollnir or anything else. It says my name, a few small flavor details, my role, and what it does. It doesn't have some elaborate bullshit back story about repeating the mod post 1000 times and calling it pertinent info.

Also, you keep claiming your role action cannot be prevented, yet you refuse to claim? Why? Do you not understand how you are contradicting yourself? If you really are town, then full claim. It's either that or you waste all of Day 1 screwing around not finding real scum, because you've made the entire focus of the game on you. You could end that focus by claiming, which might explain more than what you have (which is nothing), and then someone else can be lynched, but you refuse. It doesn't make sense, because if your role action can't be prevented anyway, then claiming to save yourself from the noose is the obvious correct play.

Simply put, I agree with Voth 100% on this. My vote doesn't move unless you claim, since the things youve said in this game should mean you have no reason not to unless you were lying.

[fiS]

I will try to look at this game again later today with more detail and try to find leads. However, rationally Jessup appears to be a bad candidate for lynch today.

[fiS]

I have no idea where to look though, with all that off topic talk and Jessup train I have no reads.

[fiS]

I will actually

unvote Jessup

[Jessup]

I'm not claiming tonight. We have 24 more hours and I need 2 votes still. I may claim tomorrow all depending in morning, Obvious reasons not to role reveal are that Towns game chances could be hurt and offenive info can be leaked to scum in process which will again hurt towns chances..

I'd love to see if

Valkyrie would claim town too as she is in the narrative

with me. Someone out here is her. 99% sure. She could be the key to proving I am town.

The closest I can get now is admitting I have the same situation zeebu had in the tolkswagon game. The narrative on page 1 is about me., page 1 , post #3 is about me and it confirms that town is fighting

the enemies of Asgard and we are fighting Chitauri in particular.

Also that the hammer has been destroyed.

[Voth]

So Jessup... about that full roleclaim I asked for and you have yet to provide?

If you do not roleclaim, at least give us a formidable reason as to why you will not.