Mafia 2020 #3: 14 Stories Above the Sea

[the_paul]

What are the odds that Willby would put an odd night and an even night serial killer in the game? Gotta be pretty low right? Something about Ixt not using his ability at all night 1 is really sticking with me for some reason, and I'm having trouble coming to terms with 2 protection claims so far

[kthx]

What are the odds that Willby would put an odd night and an even night serial killer in the game? Gotta be pretty low right? Something about Ixt not using his ability at all night 1 is really sticking with me for some reason, and I'm having trouble coming to terms with 2 protection claims so far

I think the second protective claim was a bullshit one if you mean beast.

[Beast]

you thought I was 50 proof? Nah. 100 proof!

[Edify]

Pay close attention to who is voting on me because I seem 'too townie'. That is the very identity I have, so I don't particularly see any issue with how I'm purportedly behaving. Get something that holds more water than 'too townie'.

In the beginning of the game I had wondered if there was a role that wins by hanging. Unfortunately it was not easy to find that in the wiki so I gave up. Now from Kthx I know that role is called Jester. That led me to withdraw my vote on Beast. Like Veh said, I have been after Beast all game. I'm more town than Beast is, as a vanilla townie is better than a Jester townie 10 out of 10 times. I find my posts coherent- obviously I wouldn't write them otherwise.

People accusing me of incoherence and thin arguments need to take a harsh look at what they're doing because right now this townie neck is going into the town's own bloody noose.

[Beast]

ohh did u take my vote off? brain hurts,

UNVOTE EDIFY

VOTE VEHICLE

edd..you better not let me down!

[Beast]

low key think voth is scum this go around lol, possibly god father. which means there's probably only one to two baddies left!

[ixt]

beast, your only reasons for accusation on voth are of two ways:

1. voth intended to vote backwards to cause some "conflict of interest" that seemingly separates the two but forgot to retract vote
2. voth is a dirty bitch who sells his own teammates to make himself look more town

your valid argument is only #1 as voth is not nearly as dumb to do #2, especially on DAY 1. you have to take the order of voting into account as well, voth SECOND after exalt. And mind you, I did not fully reach to the conclusion of "accusing" yet, just organizing thoughts in various scenarios.

[ixt]

vehicle and paulie d are expressing the same indirect desire to find a way to push me

vote vehicle

[Edify]

354: kthx votes ixt | 441 kthx changes to Edify
357: Exalt votes Hookecho | 412: Exalt changes to PartyFalcon
363: Kass votes halp
380: Voth votes Edify
418: Vehicle votes Hookecho | 427: Vehicle changes to Beast
432: Edify votes Beast | 437 Edify unvotes Beast
436: Hookecho votes Beast
446: Beast votes Edify | 455 Beast changes to Vehicle
458: ixt votes Vehicle

Here's my VC based on post#s since the change to D2

PartyFalcon 1 (Exalt)
Halp 1 (Kassius)
Edify 2 (kthx,Voth)
Beast 2 (Vehicle,Hook)
Vehicle 2 (Beast, ixt)

[Edify]

I'm growing more certain that Beast is jester. It fits with the wildly flying posts. Jester wins or shares a victory if lynched- then usually the game proceeds on until one of the main teams (mafia or town) wins and shares the victory with them. To me it doesn't matter if Beast wins by lynch, or loses some other way. Just as long as town's best interests are kept in play. Beast if you are a jester and you can be swayed please help the town.

I know Exalt has mentioned he'd easily vote on me which would bring my count to 3. Mafia just has to sit back and let town kill me and that's one less townie for the ship. I am trying to think through whether Vehicle warrants my vote or not. Honestly he hasn't stuck out very much. I'm going to re-read his posts. Beast is obviously just voting Vehicle because Vehicle voted on him (more Jester behavior). And there's also ixt voting on Vehicle..

Ixt is a loose cannon. Do I believe his claim or not? He's structured his claim in a manner that allows no one to question it. Which is of course how you want it to be.

[ixt]

I'm growing more certain that Beast is jester. It fits with the wildly flying posts. Jester wins or shares a victory if lynched- then usually the game proceeds on until one of the main teams (mafia or town) wins and shares the victory with them. To me it doesn't matter if Beast wins by lynch, or loses some other way. Just as long as town's best interests are kept in play. Beast if you are a jester and you can be swayed please help the town.

I know Exalt has mentioned he'd easily vote on me which would bring my count to 3. Mafia just has to sit back and let town kill me and that's one less townie for the ship. I am trying to think through whether Vehicle warrants my vote or not. Honestly he hasn't stuck out very much. I'm going to re-read his posts. Beast is obviously just voting Vehicle because Vehicle voted on him (more Jester behavior). And there's also ixt voting on Vehicle..

Ixt is a loose cannon. Do I believe his claim or not? He's structured his claim in a manner that allows no one to question it. Which is of course how you want it to be.

the way you've structured this speaks u doubt my claim. then why not just say it outright? say u dont believe my claim and that im mafia in your perspective. no need for wishy-washy

[PartyFalcon]

Why do you think I'm scum when I claimed cop, yet there doesnt seem to be a counter claim?

Why would scum me NK Jessup of all people?

1. That sure sounds like you’re trying to smoke out a cop claim on day 2. I repeat my prior advice: please nobody make claims unless you have actionable results to report.

2. Jessup was going HAM against you, Exalt. See, e.g. #’s 139, 142, 146.

Also, the_paul I do not believe I accused you—you could be scum but I think it’s just as likely you were just there when it all happened and hopped on the successful train (IIRC you reportedly weren’t sure what the count was). It’s the one minute delay between exalt’s and voth’s votes to start the train on sdrawkcab that I find the most suspicious / questionable, since town can’t PM.

[Edify]

I will say this. This current behavior is contradictory to how your first few posts of the game were. You were first-poster and all set to be the most active participant, even criticizing others for not checking in during the first few hours of the game. I put a vote on you then.

Now you're "meh" and don't even have time to play? What's wrong, did us lynching your mafia roleblocker make you give up?

Your role claim sounds manufactured and abrupt. Probably scum as I suspected back on D1.

ixt I have said so previously. Here you go bud.

[ixt]

ok then. vote edify you should run for president!

[WillBy]

Vote Tally:
edify-3 (ixt,voth, kthx)
beast-2 (vehicle, hookecho, edify)
vehicle, halp, PF-1

Missing votes: Edify, party falcon, the_paul, Halp

Still planning on changing tomorrow afternoon at some point. Let’s say 2pm CDT.