Mafia 2020 #3: 14 Stories Above the Sea

[Jessup]

wtf kass ur being a fuk fuk now..

I'm trying to lay basic groundwork and ur playing word games on me .. whatever dude

Unvote Exalt

Vote Kassius

[ixt]

Now there comes an important d1 question...do we push for a day 1 lynch on limited info? As I recall from every mafia game I’ve played so far that has a d1 lynch, almost all (I’m not sure for certain and too lazy to check all history) have been wrongfully accused town so it’s up in the air.

tl:dr benefit of not lynching is losing potentially an extra townie giving mafia/third party a free interval. Setback, less info to go on for day 2.

[Exalt]

What's the VC?

[Jessup]

. I think I'm going to be targeted by scum tonight fwiw.

Also Kass why do you feel like this? If you want to play word games.. That is a classic bait and switch tactic of scum.. I see no reason at all why mafia would target you a new player focusing on things like votes for halp because he posted b4 reading role way early in joking manner and then voting for beast because he reveals info and then me for trying my best to get town dialog going to expose mafia.. srsly u seeming fishy as fk atm suddenly and its not just because of this last vote on me ur 3rd switcheroo. I've seen nothing from you yet trying to build unity. SCUMMMY

Also ur bartender reveal seemed very reactionary and semi bogus to me..sigh

[Kassius]

Also Kass why do you feel like this? If you want to play word games.. That is a classic bait and switch tactic of scum.. I see no reason at all why mafia would target you a new player focusing on things like votes for halp because he posted b4 reading role way early in joking manner and then voting for beast because he reveals info and then me for trying my best to get town dialog going to expose mafia.. srsly u seeming fishy as fk atm suddenly and its not just because of this last vote on me ur 3rd switcheroo. I've seen nothing from you yet trying to build unity. SCUMMMY

Also ur bartender reveal seemed very reactionary and semi bogus to me..sigh

Because I'm being analytical, which is a dangerous trait to portray as it's a threat to scum.

Switcheroo? I'll change my vote 99 times a day if there's 99 pieces of information, there's very little to go on right now to prove townie membership. Scum can trip up and reveal what they know.

Also, the mere act of voting someone and seeing their reaction can potentially provide information. Got nothing out of Halp or Beast, but got a nice response from you.

Answer me this, if I was scum, why would I vote Halp, see him rise to top of vote charts, then steer it away to either Beast or yourself who were both not leading? It makes no sense. If anything, I'd have pushed the Halp agenda and tried to cement his lynching.

You're clinging on Jess.

[Jessup]

I'm just trying to be up front day 1 which seems to be making me a target. I'm willing to accept that focus for towns purposes in game if it can maybe expose some cracks and help. I hope you realize this is how I play. Mafia knows I'm not one of them. I'm trying to help not hurt .. ok. That said I'll be quiet for a while as it seems I'm not helping myself.

Unvote Kassius

[Voth]

Just something to throw out there so I can circle back to it if needed. Exalt threw out a vote with no reasoning provided on Jessup shortly after I did and has pretty much not even acknowledged anything I've said all game or called out any of the wild bullshit people are spewing from all angles. Not like him and could point to a scum or third party alignment trying to fly under the radar. Town Exalt is a lot more direct and forceful, even on Day 1. What's up Exalt?

[the_paul]

What an absolute shitshow. I'll have to read back through this after the vote count is updated, but a lot of these "arguments" have seemed extremely forced. A lot of calling someone out, arguing with them, you each vote for each other, and then just as quickly both votes are changed. I'd be willing to bet that at least 1 of these interactions is just posturing for later in the game. As it is, I don't have a single clue who could possibly be leading in votes at this point. Good luck sorting through this Willby.

[Jessup]

Any word about the inactives willby? My final vote may go to one of them this phase but if there are going to be subs that could make me change my mind.

[Vehicle]

Also, I am the only townie here. You alien doppelgangers all admitted as much when you said you work on this ship. I'm just a passenger.

Theme will be a cruise in isolation due to disease, circa 1996. Who can stand being around so many of the same people, day after day? Players will be staff members aboard the crew trying to keep everyone happy and apart from the world.

Unvote backwards VOTE EXALT

First of all, it's either feast or famine with you guys. The last two games were like pulling teeth to get anyone to post, now we're 9 pages deep on the first day phase and I am admittedly confused about half of what's going on in this thread.

I did, however, remember Willby's explanation of the game in the sign-up thread and then ran across Exalt posting that he's "just a passenger," which doesn't seem to fit in with the rules/theme of the game. At best I'm thinking Exalt is some third-party (with an insane angle since he does love to role play), at worst I'm thinking he's mafia. And, from my experience, third party roles are either neutral or anti-town (ie: survivor), so I'm voting for him.

The rest of this noise seems to be semantic fighting, although Beast's roleclaim does seem a little sus.

[WillBy]

What an absolute shitshow. I'll have to read back through this after the vote count is updated, but a lot of these "arguments" have seemed extremely forced. A lot of calling someone out, arguing with them, you each vote for each other, and then just as quickly both votes are changed. I'd be willing to bet that at least 1 of these interactions is just posturing for later in the game. As it is, I don't have a single clue who could possibly be leading in votes at this point. Good luck sorting through this Willby.

I’ve seen worse.

Vote Tally:
beast-2 (edify, voth)
jessup-2 (kassius, exalt)
voth-2 (ixt, the_paul)
exalt-2 (Hookecho, vehicle)
bioture-1 (beast)
kassius-1 (jessup)
halp-1 (sdrawkcab)
ixt-1 (halp)


Missing votes: Missa, Bioture. I am considering subs. I'd also like to see more activity from Hookecho. If anyone seems him online in spaceships, please remind him to post

[the_paul]

Jesus after all of that we end up with a 4 way tie?

[Jessup]

My current vote count came to this Willby. Ixt and I unvoted. I know u put in italics.. this is actual vote I believe.


Vote Tally:

jessup- 2 (, exalt,kassius)
exalt-2 (,hookecho,vehicle)
beast-2 (edify, voth)
bioture-1 (beast)
halp- 1 ( sdrawkcab)
ixt- 1 ( halp)
sdrawkcab- 1 (vehicle)
voth- 1 (the_paul)

[WillBy]

I feel like this is also a good opportunity to remind people of our special rules.

Ties will result result in double lynches. The first two players to reach the tie will be lynched. At the moment that looks like beast and jessup (due to ixt unvoting- I typically dont count unvotes, but will consider it in this case).

I do allow vote abstains on day 1, for those who dont want a day 1 lynch. If abstain wins over 50% (7 players, +- 2 for inactives), we will move into night without a lynch.

[Jessup]

Ok is it Noon Eastern Standard Time phase will end or? I hate this cause it like I'm forced now to self survival vote for exalt if I must but am hoping he backtracks. I don't get why exalt is even voting for me. Wanna talk here Exalt? I'd rather not vote for you.