[Mafia] Someone is Watching

[Voth]

GG. I fumbled the ball for sure. For what it's worth, though, here's a screenshot of me telling Jacklyn super early in D1 that townies had to visit people at night.



I genuinely thought I had made it clear early in D1 I knew town had to visit people at night. When I started catching votes for "not knowing" I was really thrown off. It sucked but there was no way out of it so I just ran with the ball. What can ya do?

At least Voth gets an new forum handle out of the deal. That is, unless he's not a man of his word.

Showing that you knew that early on and still managed to come off scummy and like the kid who inappropriately inserts himself into other families' vacations doesn't make you look good. It makes you look like you're really bad at this game.

It's hard to be proud of you at times like this, my son.

[Voth]

Forum handle updated to reflect the facts.

[Vehicle]

I feel like killing Voth would've framed me a bit harder. Most people weren't thrilled about my roleblock, and killing Voth IS what I would've done. But it was rock/hard place anyways, you were caught in the same spot as me but I had the global thing to bail me out.

A Voth kill would of probably been the best move. I can't imagine what kind of messages I would of gotten on the dead players chat if that's what I did.




I think targeting you N1 would of been a bad play. In fact, you would of survived it because of Solid. Someone in town is basically guaranteed to use their PR on you. Jackie and I each had 2-shot abilities so I figured town was full of 1-shot investigative roles because of the game name. I thought the odds of getting a kill on you AND not being seen N1 were very low.

It's also not easy to swing town as a 2-person team, regardless of the players, and you can't really afford to lose someone D2 because they got caught (clearly). Not killing you was really a defensive move as much as it seems like it fucked us.


Edit: I edited this post to move paragraphs around because I misread Willby's original post. The overall content and message remain the same.

[WillBy]

I shit the bed the end of N1. I thought I had built more town cred than I actually had. But you try going into D2 with 7 players, 3 of which are confirmed town (basically), 2 of which are Jessup and Soliderz and 2 of which are scum. Regardless of whether Willby was alive, TP/Voth weren't voting each other. If I killed Willby instead of Exalt, would Exalt of voted for TP/Voth?

I feel like killing Voth would've framed me a bit harder. Most people weren't thrilled about my roleblock, and killing Voth IS what I would've done. But it was rock/hard place anyways, you were caught in the same spot as me but I had the global thing to bail me out.

[Jessup]

Originally posted by Voth View Post
I am not normally one to toot my own horn,

lol. What sound does it make? Would you describe it as a dingle? Perhaps a doink?

Bahahahahahah

[Vehicle]

As far as balance I don't really see how the traveling around every night benefits or hurts anyone. It would confuse town, but only by the tiniest bit, as everyone would know something was up.

Exalt Having a free RB on Willby knowing he'll be watched N1, why kill him when you can just block him and kill him the next day? Our actions were submitted well before your late-night post. Maybe that's on me for not reading forums religiously, but just because it wasn't your play doesn't mean it's a bad play.

I shit the bed the end of N1. I thought I had built more town cred than I actually had. But you try going into D2 with 7 players, 3 of which are confirmed town (basically), 2 of which are Jessup and Soliderz and 2 of which are scum. Regardless of whether Willby was alive, TP/Voth weren't voting each other. If I killed Willby instead of Exalt, would Exalt of voted for TP/Voth?

I definitely got myself lynched, but it was largely because of the one critical miscalculation of not more-loudly saying "hey, we all have to visit one person at night." I guess I have more to learn from Exalt.

[Vehicle]

I am not normally one to toot my own horn,

lol. What sound does it make? Would you describe it as a dingle? Perhaps a doink?

[Vehicle]

GG. I fumbled the ball for sure. For what it's worth, though, here's a screenshot of me telling Jacklyn super early in D1 that townies had to visit people at night.



I genuinely thought I had made it clear early in D1 I knew town had to visit people at night. When I started catching votes for "not knowing" I was really thrown off. It sucked but there was no way out of it so I just ran with the ball. What can ya do?

At least Voth gets an new forum handle out of the deal. That is, unless he's not a man of his word.

[Jessup]

GG everyone.

Glad the willby thing didn't go through. I was baiting throwing my vote back on Willby day 2 to see reactions. As dumb as it was .. the Voth and Willby day 1 antics was very fortunate for town and horrible for mafia.

I agree 3 mafia would perhaps have been better. A mafia 1 shot busdriver could have countered. The balance for this type setup is hard to determine because this game was totally dictated by Willby revealing day1 so it is hard to say how this scenario plays out with a dead global watcher or a D2 town lynch. I did like the traveling town idea by LF.

Jacklyn was in my radar partly because she was being fringe like I was. I felt I had leverage on the peripherals as a VT to test other waters and create turbulence elsewhere. Jacklyn.. exalts advice is good if you are new and if you are, that role you had was a REALLY tough one as a first.

Thanks a lot for the host LF was fun

[Exalt]

Day 1: could've killed WillBy, but chose Beast instead? Mistake #1

Day 2: Jacklyn being super obvious along with Vehicle trying to take out Voth. Just bad decision after bad decision.

Also, Jacklyn when someone asks your role, either say you don't want to tell them or say an actual role. Don't say 'I'm a Townie' as if that's a role. It isn't. Lie if you have to.

I called Jacklyn scum N1 btw. I'd have gone to vehicle too Day 2 after the Voth interaction. Willby made his case at that point to he removed from suspicion.

I think the scum team needed 3 people imo, especially with someone so new at it in Jacklyn

[Soilderz]

I am not normally one to toot my own horn, but I will anyway because you all can suck me. You all suck. Willby was super scummy but our interaction got me to where I needed to go. Hence why I didn't hesitate once on Vehicle the next day. Thanks Willby - next time maybe we can be civil - but I think our interaction lulled the "tards," as they shall be known as going forward, into a false sense of security.

LOL.


GG Town and thanks for hosting LF! I thought the whole game idea was interesting. If there was like 15-20 people playing that would've been such a fun clusterfuck for the Watcher to analyze!

[WillBy]

3 game unbeaten streak, ty4this town!

gg guys, thanks for the host LF!

Tp host so I can tie you up

[the_paul]

3 game unbeaten streak, ty4this town!

gg guys, thanks for the host LF!

[Voth]

I legit thought you were baiting people the whole time. Had to play it up and see who we could catch.

I was and I wasn't. Nothing like a good blood feud to stoke the fires and make everyone else feel at ease if they aren't part of it. But I did think you were scum until Vehicle lost the game for his whole team by making it so obvious when he tried to be the kid that fit in who just shit his pants.

[WillBy]

I am not normally one to toot my own horn, but I will anyway because you all can suck me. You all suck. Willby was super scummy but our interaction got me to where I needed to go. Hence why I didn't hesitate once on Vehicle the next day. Thanks Willby - next time maybe we can be civil - but I think our interaction lulled the "tards," as they shall be known as going forward, into a false sense of security.

I legit thought you were baiting people the whole time. Had to play it up and see who we could catch.