mvp

[Richard Creager]

Unless someone can figure out a way to grant MVP to reward TEAMPLAY

It's called winning the game.

[Troll King]

I think you missed my point. It's a team game, or is supposed to be.

Taken from the TW web site...
"Welcome to SSCU Trench Wars, an exciting team-based game platform."

"Primarily created as a team-based flagging game..."

"Your primary mission in Trench Wars is to help your team..."

Therefore it is my opinion that any MVP should be primarily based upon team play, not individual play. As such, see my previous statement.

Wait a minute there... if your argument is that TW is first and foremost a team game, then your opinion should be that there shouldn't be an MVP. Those two concepts are polar opposites. If you want to decide MVP based on team play then by definition you shouldn't be able to come up with one player. If you're using those arguments to show that a player on a losing team shouldn't be MVP, then someone else can use the exact same arguments to show that there shouldn't even be an MVP at all.

[Ephemeral]

Wait a minute there... if your argument is that TW is first and foremost a team game, then your opinion should be that there shouldn't be an MVP. Those two concepts are polar opposites. If you want to decide MVP based on team play then by definition you shouldn't be able to come up with one player. If you're using those arguments to show that a player on a losing team shouldn't be MVP, then someone else can use the exact same arguments to show that there shouldn't even be an MVP at all.

TK, please read up two posts. I say, "Unless someone can figure out a way to grant MVP to reward TEAMPLAY, I say get rid of it."

I know of no way, other than a human watching and making this kind of judgement call, that this could be done through stats or code logic. But I was leaving the door open in case my deep and incredible intelligence had missed something that you guys could come up with. LOL

[Nockm]

I believe a large detour has taken part in this thread. There are two different styles of MVP, duel and base. I was discussing the duel MVP formula, and I am certain the posters before me were discussing duel MVP too (not base).

I would advise taking the base MVP ideas to a seperate thread and duel MVP discussions remain here.

[Sumpson]

MVP shouldn't be a surprise after game, it should be something wich makes the game more competitive, with a clear goal as MVP I think this is possible.

EDIT: Oh yah, the "Perfect MVP" you want is simply not possible, there is no need for eighter.

[Ephemeral]

I believe a large detour has taken part in this thread. There are two different styles of MVP, duel and base. I was discussing the duel MVP formula, and I am certain the posters before me were discussing duel MVP too (not base).

I would advise taking the base MVP ideas to a seperate thread and duel MVP discussions remain here.

I couldn't tell if the thread starter (triceratops) was referring to Base and/or Dual. I am sorry if I caused any confusion, I'll shut up now.

[pascone]

I think you missed my point. It's a team game, or is supposed to be.

Taken from the TW web site...
"Welcome to SSCU Trench Wars, an exciting team-based game platform."

"Primarily created as a team-based flagging game..."

"Your primary mission in Trench Wars is to help your team..."

Therefore it is my opinion that any MVP should be primarily based upon team play, not individual play. As such, see my previous statement.

..........


what is baseball?
basketball?
football?


etc




team sports....they have mvps


and last year arod was mvp and his team sucked so it really doesnt matter

[Ephemeral]

..........


what is baseball?
basketball?
football?
etc
team sports....they have mvps
and last year arod was mvp and his team sucked so it really doesnt matter

And they give MVP's for every game? No, they do not. Those sports (at least most) have MVP based upon voting at the end of the season (usually voting by fans or sportswriters). So I guess I am missing your point on how voting for a league MVP at the end of a season in these professional sports relates to giving out a MVP during every on-line game.

[Dameon Angell]

I believe a large detour has taken part in this thread. There are two different styles of MVP, duel and base. I was discussing the duel MVP formula, and I am certain the posters before me were discussing duel MVP too (not base).

I would advise taking the base MVP ideas to a seperate thread and duel MVP discussions remain here.

Damnit I will


btw: Duel MVP should be (Kills - Deaths) - (spawn kills) = MVP score

[Bioture]

MVP should always be the guy with the best Wins minus Losses.

So much for my dreams of being shark mvp.