SEASON 30 PLAYER RATINGS (discussion)

[HellzNo!]

2024
zid 8* (0 games, while being cap, so obviously did not consider himself worth a while playing) (power made it to finals)
tj 7* 45-53 rec, similar stats to zapata (8.5) in poor pure luck team, played whenever he showe

2023 fall -
zid 8* (ranked in bottom 10), played 4 games 15-38 rec (power won wb that season)
tj 6.5* played 6 games, won 5 with 38-42 rec (similar to ppl like spawnisen, spartan, hulk etc)

Now it does not make sense putting zid to 8.5, if you dont want to lower him, then at least keep his 8, but isnt the point of rating review to check how person has done rated at something and then correct for next league.
Zids form in wb has been in decline for last couple of years, while tj has shown similar quality both as 6.5 and 7 in last 2 leagues and has been important member in lineup and deserves a bump to 7.5 for sure. Zid is case of someone who can probably get up to his old 8.5 level if he pracs and takes this seriously, but rather trend shows he does not care about that in wb.

I agree recent performances should be taken into consideration, and obviously counting stats are an easy indicator of who's been playing more regularly and showing better results. But there is something to be said for the "eye test," being able to see when a player has an impact on a game and their ship/teaming IQ make up for the K/D ratio.

I'm not even really disagreeing with you about Zid's rating, I just have a hard time placing them on the same tier. Could be way off though, I stink at wb

[Zizzo]

I think the ratings should also factor in the number of games played previous season(s). For example I got zero playing time in wb and one game in javelin last season as an 8 so obviously I'm overrated. (not to mention why am I rated the same for both when I've only ever played handful of dds and hundreds of jds?)

[kentaro]

i'd like to base and would be more motivated to show if I was added but at 7.5 I don't get much playing time. Over the past like 5 years i've prob only played a couple of games in DTB and its not like i've ever overachieved. without getting some games in I wont get any better but requesting a consideration to move my base rating to 7. I have never really played that league compared to others at the same rating