All-stars Voting

[Colonel]

HAHAHA deluge calling people mediocre when he aint even close to being mediocre or on the same level as geisha and dep. :ermm:

soooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo ez

[Underground]

dep is very good and well.. considering geisha is by far the best wb this season, deluge shows how much he knows about this game.

[Ephemeral]

Is someone a 'All Star' if they are a good (skillful) player but do things that hurt TW in general?

It looks like statistics will be used by many people (since they are listed on All Star form) but we all know the stats have many mistakes in them. (Like when a player is in two different ships in the same game.)

How can anyone who played in only 3 games the entire season be considered an All Star (isn't showing up and supporting your squad important)?

How can voting start when some teams still have games to play while others do not? Is this not unfair to those players who did not have the opportunity to play all games?

[demonfaze]

dep is very good and well.. considering geisha is by far the best wb this season, deluge shows how much he knows about this game.

Uhhh... Statistically Colonel without a doubt had the best regular season in TWLD, so I don't know how you came up with your conclusion about Geisha.

[Izor]

yeah i dont get how you can say geisha had the best season either when obviously col has. besides, sk8 has terrible teaming with that newbie in, why else do you think you lost to boz of all squads. hf choking in playoffs again

[RednaZ]

At risk of getting flamed I dare say colonel had a better team backing him and in that light geisha did better

[Bill C]

Just a suggestion because I know most of the All-Stars are going to be from a few select squads. Perhaps if the rules were changed and only a maximum of 2 players could be chosen from each squad it could be a bit more fair and even players from "crappier" squads could be represented. As for the games, maybe a best of 3 and basically each all-star plays a round or at least subs :/

[Sufficient]

I hope there is a filter that says that you only can be considered on the All-Star ballot if you've played 5 games or more in the regular season.

[Izor]

Just a suggestion because I know most of the All-Stars are going to be from a few select squads. Perhaps if the rules were changed and only a maximum of 2 players could be chosen from each squad it could be a bit more fair and even players from "crappier" squads could be represented. As for the games, maybe a best of 3 and basically each all-star plays a round or at least subs :/

Do you see an abundance of royals in the mlb all star game? Why would suckier teams have people in? Makes no sense to me

[Underground]

Uhhh... Statistically Colonel without a doubt had the best regular season in TWLD, so I don't know how you came up with your conclusion about Geisha.

Geisha: 9 games: score 96-45 with one loss.
Colonel: 10 games 109 - 45 all wins

"statistically without a doubt" ?! is that what u said?
And apart from it, isnt Syndicate the "powerhouse" ?
oh and not even saying your schedule is easier.

I dont expect any smart comments by demonfaze anyways.

[Colonel]

btw UG... we've only played 9... Bot died out during UF game... remember? thank you.

EDIT: first on this page!!

[demonfaze]

Geisha: 9 games: score 96-45 with one loss.
Colonel: 10 games 109 - 45 all wins

"statistically without a doubt" ?! is that what u said?
And apart from it, isnt Syndicate the "powerhouse" ?
oh and not even saying your schedule is easier.

I dont expect any smart comments by demonfaze anyways.

You should really think before you post Underground, but actually I kinda enjoy it when you make yourself look stupid.

Colonel's 109-45 is in 8 games buddy, not 10. Do the math. Our 10th game hasn't even been played yet, and our 9th game hasn't even been posted. Geisha's 96-45 is in 7 games, because one of his games was a forfeit, another he didn't show up vs -Final-, and the other hasn't been posted. If you want to count the games that haven't yet been posted then Colonel is 123-55 in 9 games, and Geisha is 107-51 in 8 games. Colonel with a 2.24 ratio and +68 +/-, Geisha with a 2.10 ratio and +56 +/-. He would of had to of gone +12 vs Final just to match Colonel. So yes, statistically "without a doubt" is right.

Our schedule is easier? Lets look at the teams Geisha played against first of all - Grapevine, Speed, BoZ, Ancients, United Force, Heavy, Squad!!!, Disoblige. Now lets look at the squads Colonel played against - Shinobi, Pirates, Speed, Warpath, -Final-, Dice, Disoblige, Heavy, BoZ. Now, if you look at those schedules, the teams that Geisha played against but Colonel didn't are - Grapevine, Ancients, United Force, and Squad!!!. Now the teams Colonel played against but Geisha didn't are - Shinobi, Pirates, Warpath, -Final-, and Dice. Notice how Geisha didn't play against Final or Dice who are both considered within the top 3-4 squads in TWLD this season. So how is it that we had an easier schedule again?

About your powerhouse comment, yes I do consider us a powerhouse considering were at the top or near the top in every league, but were talking about TWLD here aren't we. Sk8's rec in TWLD isn't much worse then Syndicate's, were 9-0 while Sk8 is 9-1, and its not like we've been playing full lineups of superstars every match. Your ld team surrounding Geisha with the likes of Ease, Creature, Vitja, Junka, etc are more then capable enough to be starters and pull their weight on any squad. The players on Syndicate that have been starting most of our matches in the regular season besides me and Colonel consist of Amputate and Confluence mainly, as well as a 5th player cycling every week, are you to say that Amp and Conf totally outclass your starters surrounding Geisha? Give me a break. Bottom line is not only is Colonel's stats way better then Geisha's, but he also showed up to all of the tough games and went 18-9 vs Final, and 14-4 vs Dice, while Geisha didn't even show up against Final and is still inferior stat-wise to Colonel. What else do you have to say Underground?

[Izor]

still bitter over them leaving?

[Colonel]

Lol Underground Just Got Owned Like Portugal Got Owned By France... Vive Le France!

[megaman89]

enough of this lets talk about how good underground and I are