2009 * Rating Thread

[Exalt]

Kid Kaos was 65-76 last season in TWL, so 7 is a fair ranking
Exalt was 84-74 so you could argue he's an 8 or a 7, depending on your definition of "impact"

define "impact" for me burnt I mvped for my team almost every game, carried a big game when i needed to that would've decided playoffs or not when my team was struggling, and basically was alone with unabled when geio left midseason, rest of the squad was inactive, and kk was rusty, and managed to take the squad to playoffs, I think i did fairly well... oh and was top 5 in twl stats in wb, although I dont really care if im a 7 or 8 in twdt, but the point was worth mentioning that I disagreed, and another post I read said 7 was a player who started like 2 twl games and 8 was reg twl starter... so its why i was wondering wtf was up

Cres, 7 is consistent TWL starter, what squad have you started for again?
You're lucky to get a 6 considering you don't even average 1:1 in TWD (http://twd.trenchwars.org/profile/85291/stats) but according to: http://www.trenchwars.org/index.php?...&sb.x=6&sb.y=6 you're using 1280x800 resolution so how can you expect to be near as good as the players who use 1280x1024 and see over 25% more of the screen?

Overall the ratings a pretty good, not perfect but almost no one is more than 1 rating point off where they should be.

i'll agree, most players are around where they should be, or only 1 point off

some are a little overrated, but they are overrated despite twdt, not because of it, so its fine

in defense to cres though, most of evil isn't even 1:1 or is barely 1:1 in twd average too, but I'm sure cres probably cares a little more since he is a newer up and coming player

[Kid Kaos]

I only started like 2 games for dynasty including the twld playoff vs HEAVY. Most of the rest are from sub-ins. I was not very active for most of last TWL.

[Cuji]

I should be 4-3-4 (bottom of the list! )

[tragiK]

from: http://forums.trenchwars.org/showpos...67&postcount=8
6 = impact TWD player/ started 1 or 2 games TWL games
7 = consistent TWL starter
8 = impact player
9 = top 10 in league
10 = top 3-5 in league

Kid Kaos was 65-76 last season in TWL, so 7 is a fair ranking
Exalt was 84-74 so you could argue he's an 8 or a 7, depending on your definition of "impact"


Cres, 7 is consistent TWL starter, what squad have you started for again?
You're lucky to get a 6 considering you don't even average 1:1 in TWD (http://twd.trenchwars.org/profile/85291/stats) but according to: http://www.trenchwars.org/index.php?...&sb.x=6&sb.y=6 you're using 1280x800 resolution so how can you expect to be near as good as the players who use 1280x1024 and see over 25% more of the screen?

Overall the ratings a pretty good, not perfect but almost no one is more than 1 rating point off where they should be.

this is why burnt was asked to captain again

Why do you ppl care so much about those ratings LOL
its not like a number will define how good u play

[Burnt]

if 8 is a twl starter 9 is a twl impact player and 7 is a player who only played 1-2 twl games

then why the fuck are me and kk 7s? stupid rankings really, but it doesnt matter

with the way some people are ranked, its obvious a lot of players don't know how to judge other players' skill levels

from: http://forums.trenchwars.org/showpos...67&postcount=8
6 = impact TWD player/ started 1 or 2 games TWL games
7 = consistent TWL starter
8 = impact player
9 = top 10 in league
10 = top 3-5 in league

Kid Kaos was 65-76 last season in TWL, so 7 is a fair ranking
Exalt was 84-74 so you could argue he's an 8 or a 7, depending on your definition of "impact"


Cres, 7 is consistent TWL starter, what squad have you started for again?
You're lucky to get a 6 considering you don't even average 1:1 in TWD (http://twd.trenchwars.org/profile/85291/stats) but according to: http://www.trenchwars.org/index.php?...&sb.x=6&sb.y=6 you're using 1280x800 resolution so how can you expect to be near as good as the players who use 1280x1024 and see over 25% more of the screen?

Overall the ratings a pretty good, not perfect but almost no one is more than 1 rating point off where they should be.

[Exalt]

if 8 is a twl starter 9 is a twl impact player and 7 is a player who only played 1-2 twl games

then why the fuck are me and kk 7s? stupid rankings really, but it doesnt matter

with the way some people are ranked, its obvious a lot of players don't know how to judge other players' skill levels

[PhyRe]

lol

the rating system is horrible, how did mattey score higher in WB than me or cres lol

[ignite ignite]

All this argument on what your ratings are is so pointless. Ultimately, it depends on who the captain is that drafts you, if you are so lucky as to be drafted. I see dozens of people that I'd never want on my team that have applied for this draft. Anyways, a good captain won't go by the little star and number they have put by your name, but rather from experience...

[Crescent Seal]

fail, cres 6-4-4

more like
8-2-3

k maybe a 7-2-3 :P

[Crescent Seal]

fail, cres 6-4-4

more like
8-2-3

[Stabwound]

red alert red alert I have been underrated in a meaningless poll of random space players!!!!!!!!!!! what an outrage!!!!! i once got a positive record this is fucking bullshit i hate this game!!!!!!!!!!!!!

p.s. i can't wait to play!!!!!! :-)

[Cranium]

So yea, apologies for not noticing this earlier, I probably should've said something before but I really didn't notice it until I had a sample of your ratings. Anyways, my personal re-vamped rankings:

11* - Lebron james
10* - Top 5/10 (or any other fucking number I don't care) player in your league
9* - Impact TWL starter
8* - Consistent TWL starter
7* - Started 1-2 TWL matches / TWL Sub
6* - Impact TWD player
5* - Average to above Average TWD player
4* - Low Average to Poor TWD player
3* - First time TWD'er
2* - Pubber
1* - If you are given a 1* rating you are being alias checked or are potentially a cheater and are being verified by staff.

Obviously a TWL sub should be the same as "started 1-2 TWL matches", since they're most likely the 6th or 7th wb/jav/spider.

And even with this ranking, I personally think 6 and 7 could be combined. Many squads will have players who've proven themselves consistently in TWD (that's what impact twd player means right?) play 1 or 2 TWL games to get some experience. In your ranking, the difference between 9 and 10 affects, well fuck let's just do some math, I combined top 5 and top 10, so that's 5 players per league out of 3 leagues = 15 fucking players. Whereas separating lower categories would affect more players, even if they are lesser known and have smaller egos. But hey, this isn't a fucking slaveship where you give 30 white sailors hammocks and rum while cramming 500 africans into the cargo hold. Plus it bumps up the ratings of a few more TWL dudes which should force the caps to draft a few less "top" players and more regular ones.



So re-vamping my re-vamped rankings

11* - Lebron james
10* - Top 5/10 (or any other fucking number I don't care) player in your league
9* - Impact TWL starter
8* - Consistent TWL starter
7* - Started 1-2 TWL matches / TWL Sub / Impact TWD player
6* - Average to above Average TWD player
5* - Low Average to Poor TWD player
4* - First time TWD'er
3* - Pubber
2* - Anyone who has two hands
1* - If you are given a 1* rating you are being alias checked or are potentially a cheater and are being verified by staff.

leme get this right... 11* - lebron? he too busy chokin on cock at home watching the finals

[tragiK]

I wanna play this.

Sign me up. :wub:

signup thread is ---> that way

[Raspi]

I wanna play this.

Sign me up. :wub: