2009 * Rating Thread

[Golden_Aim]

I liked this thread. Eventho, i suppose this isnt alltime rating just the best players atm... Maketso should be a 10 in jav since he outplayed them all in twlj finals, getting the most kills, mvp. altho his team lost it..


OFFTOPIC:
I came up with an idea Instead of the old allstars match concept in twl, we could have some kind of voting+stats average result to decide the mvp player of each league, and add the mvp to historybook with winners.. like best wb, jav, terr, spid, shark, this league.. The best players could get some spacerespect just my 2 cents

[Downfall]

Wax most underrated jav in tw.


Why is this thread still alive? Is humid still adding new people to the list or are more people starting to bitch about their rating.

[Exalt]

maybe you shouldn't average the ratings considering how bad some of them are and how wrong they are on a lot of players

Its not hard for people who dislike/like a player to give biased ratings. The disliked player will give really low ones while the liked player will give really high ones. Its not really true rankings.

Use twl site and see for yourself if brokenfist is worth the ranking he has.

Same with other players.

Twl site is a better use of figuring out who is good or not when they are supposed to be playing their best (and trying their best) compared to just random newbs from twd who rate players based on elim scores.

[squallFF8]

someone told me it was a bunch of faggots who do the ratings...



how was that not constructive?
its a valid point that geio also agreed with


i understand you've been cooped up doing these calculations all day

feel free to vent

[Shadowmere]

too much nerd babble in these places, try to avoid it


thanks for the quick info

You read the ratings but not the info directly above it in the first post?

Good going.

[squallFF8]

too much nerd babble in these places, try to avoid it


thanks for the quick info

[Summa]

oh, i see..

thats fair!

where do i vote?

you email me a set of ratings like it says in the first post, try reading

[squallFF8]

oh, i see..

thats fair!

where do i vote?

[Summa]

who does voting? and favouring?
honestly.

you do. everyone is available to submit ratings and criticisms, and i simply average them and adjust a few based on past twdt stats. i think i adjusted like 7 total, the rest are averaged. if you think the ratings are off, then obviously the people who submitted have some bias or slight against you. raples will be getting adjusted this next time, along with paska, and spikey, they have a lot of complaints. but if you didn't submit a set of ratings and you sit here talking about bias or how retarded the voters are i am just gonna disregard your opinion.

also in response to the "all of the caps are wbs" comment, no they aren't there are a few basers and no javs volunteered to cap, at least not back when i was selecting. i guess the wbs league is going to be ultra competative.

EDIT: also squall, be constructive or shut up, i have no problem deleting your posts, i don't care for bitching, and don't tell me to fix shit if you're not part of the solution, do something or shut up @ this point.

[squallFF8]

yeah, broken fist is not a better overall player than:

Fieryfire
Eelam
Spikey
Turban
Hellkite
Cripple
Racka
Raples
Ardour
Remu

Etc

fix the rating, ALOT.
plz

Jethro Tull is BrokenFist, and no he should not be rated that high IMO.

[squallFF8]

Jethro Tull ranked higher than FieryFire...
not to mention, higher than Raples and Spikey in basing
and equal in skill to Mattey???!
oh and he's better than hellkite too


Apparently Diakka is equal in bd skill to Haeduan, X machine, and apocolypse wow (who play one ship) *apoc wow is great at that one ship



who does voting? and favouring?
honestly.

[Cyrus]

i should be at 4 at both jav and wb

culex higher in javs, zizzo too and lunch3 only a 7 at basing? :/
paska 8 at both wb and jav, same for vys at jav and basing
da1 or for everything (unless you have some kind of gayness-subcompetition)
spikey 9 in basing! turban an 8 in basing, hermit 2 in everything and for myself 11 in basing

that's all

[Soilderz]

who is milpitas? and bye

[Playback]

once the tourny starts, we will see who's got all the skill!