2009 * Rating Thread

[a2m+]

ya most of the players that play in twl or are on top 10 squads average 1:1, and are ranked higher...doesnt make sense...i guess experience counts then

Alot of players don't try their hardest in twd. Also, alot of awesome twd players choke or can't play well in twl (5v5 is alot different than 4v4).

[Lock]

I didn't play TWL for the past two seasons nor did I play TWDT last season. So there is obviously some opinion put into these rankings.

[RaCka]

well im fine with it, im pretty much over the whole * rating thing anyway, I was just being a smartass

still don't see how racka is a 10* though

hope off my balls already you annoying redneck

[paradise!]

wow thanks, i just noticed im '1024x768'

>>http://www.trenchwars.org/index.php?v=pubstats&x=prof&s=rating&player=Draft& sb.x=0&sb.y=0<<

how am i so good on a small screen, cant imagine what i'll do on anything bigger lOL

I play 1024x768 as well, it's really not that big of a deal in twjd, and probably not in twbd. But in twdd, it's a significant difference.

[Crescent Seal]

define "impact" for me burnt I mvped for my team almost every game, carried a big game when i needed to that would've decided playoffs or not when my team was struggling, and basically was alone with unabled when geio left midseason, rest of the squad was inactive, and kk was rusty, and managed to take the squad to playoffs, I think i did fairly well... oh and was top 5 in twl stats in wb, although I dont really care if im a 7 or 8 in twdt, but the point was worth mentioning that I disagreed, and another post I read said 7 was a player who started like 2 twl games and 8 was reg twl starter... so its why i was wondering wtf was up




i'll agree, most players are around where they should be, or only 1 point off

some are a little overrated, but they are overrated despite twdt, not because of it, so its fine

in defense to cres though, most of evil isn't even 1:1 or is barely 1:1 in twd average too, but I'm sure cres probably cares a little more since he is a newer up and coming player

ya most of the players that play in twl or are on top 10 squads average 1:1, and are ranked higher...doesnt make sense...i guess experience counts then

[Crescent Seal]

from: http://forums.trenchwars.org/showpos...67&postcount=8
6 = impact TWD player/ started 1 or 2 games TWL games
7 = consistent TWL starter
8 = impact player
9 = top 10 in league
10 = top 3-5 in league

Kid Kaos was 65-76 last season in TWL, so 7 is a fair ranking
Exalt was 84-74 so you could argue he's an 8 or a 7, depending on your definition of "impact"


Cres, 7 is consistent TWL starter, what squad have you started for again?
You're lucky to get a 6 considering you don't even average 1:1 in TWD (http://twd.trenchwars.org/profile/85291/stats) but according to: http://www.trenchwars.org/index.php?...&sb.x=6&sb.y=6 you're using 1280x800 resolution so how can you expect to be near as good as the players who use 1280x1024 and see over 25% more of the screen?

Overall the ratings a pretty good, not perfect but almost no one is more than 1 rating point off where they should be.

Idk this is my first year on this game, i havent played twl yet so i guess that makes sense. But alot of people that make twl seem horrible when i spec or play against them and thats what i was basing my own rating on. But I guess 6 makes sense for me then. I play on laptop so i cant change my resolution to anything higher.

[Exalt]

well one, being more recent is obviously more influential, at least in terms of the ratings i filled out. other people may have solely done last twl, some people may have just said fuck humid, his rating system is retarded, let me do it my own way.....oh and i hate eelam so let me give him a rating of 12. i cannot control that. what i can say though, is that next season ardour will have the new site up and all of this will be avoided. it will become put up or shut up time, not subjective preferences.

well im fine with it, im pretty much over the whole * rating thing anyway, I was just being a smartass

still don't see how racka is a 10* though

[Summa]

well if thats the case then apok and racka clearly arent 10* wbs either

well one, being more recent is obviously more influential, at least in terms of the ratings i filled out. other people may have solely done last twl, some people may have just said fuck humid, his rating system is retarded, let me do it my own way.....oh and i hate eelam so let me give him a rating of 12. i cannot control that. what i can say though, is that next season ardour will have the new site up and all of this will be avoided. it will become put up or shut up time, not subjective preferences.

[Exalt]

its based upon the past 2 twls and the past twdt, i prefer 3 sets of statistics to draw upon (source material), rather than 1

well if thats the case then apok and racka clearly arent 10* wbs either

[Draft]

but according to: http://www.trenchwars.org/index.php?...&sb.x=6&sb.y=6 you're using 1280x800 resolution so how can you expect to be near as good as the players who use 1280x1024 and see over 25% more of the screen?

wow thanks, i just noticed im '1024x768'

>>http://www.trenchwars.org/index.php?v=pubstats&x=prof&s=rating&player=Draft& sb.x=0&sb.y=0<<

how am i so good on a small screen, cant imagine what i'll do on anything bigger lOL

[Summa]

I just dont think megaman89 deserves a 8* rating in wb especially if you are basing thise on last twld stats. The fact that dice wasnt even in TWLD last year is the main point... he didnt play a single game. so how was he a impact twld player?

its based upon the past 2 twls and the past twdt, i prefer 3 sets of statistics to draw upon (source material), rather than 1

[Kid Kaos]

I just dont think megaman89 deserves a 8* rating in wb especially if you are basing thise on last twld stats. The fact that dice wasnt even in TWLD last year is the main point... he didnt play a single game. so how was he a impact twld player?

[Summa]

I am looking to have the ratings done by this Sunday for the caps. Apps in order to be eligible for the draft are closing come Friday. If you're submitting ratings then do it soon. Also Exalt, I think you have defended yourself enough, if you prove you're good in the season then it will pay off next season when it is stat based twlm style. I would prefer if this remains slightly on topic, although I know ego bruising must occur and I have allowed for flex room.

[Exalt]

so why do you care so much? lol

was talking about the twd average at the time, twl i do care about though, and probably will see me care a lot more now with ladder reset

[tragiK]

but I'm sure cres probably cares a little more since he is a newer up and coming player

so why do you care so much? lol