TRADES

[Heaven]

Guess you are cheating ur way to victory once again. Tiny's team doesnt get better by this trade. Apparently ogron said he isnt gonna show for him... And no surprise his thunder buddy is there to pick him up. Just like you gave ro an 8 in jav, which is ridicilous.

seeing as ogron probably replaced me in terr -i can say that im not here to defend zid in a biased matter.

Ogron for the last 2 weeks has been on vacay and was not able to contact tiny. he asked me to text him on his behalf. i forwarded the messages to tiny and finally just gave him tinys number. there was no mention of 'not showing because i dont like my team/captain'. as far as i could tell from the texts he had every intention of playing. ragequitting games/weeks is a different story though.

[Majorcrisis2]

Any trade that needs to be analyzed that closely is fine. There's always going to be differences in opinions on who got the better end of the deal.

There's already been multiple people in here saying the trade is fair, tiny favored, or zid favored. Trades aren't going to come down to a vote.

If anyone is trading 7* basers let me know

Guess you are cheating ur way to victory once again. Tiny's team doesnt get better by this trade. Apparently ogron said he isnt gonna show for him... And no surprise his thunder buddy is there to pick him up. Just like you gave ro an 8 in jav, which is ridicilous.

[zidane]

Any trade that needs to be analyzed that closely is fine. There's always going to be differences in opinions on who got the better end of the deal.

There's already been multiple people in here saying the trade is fair, tiny favored, or zid favored. Trades aren't going to come down to a vote.

If anyone is trading 7* basers let me know

[Majorcrisis2]

Sorry, colors are based on star rating otherwise it doesn't make sense for jav and wb. I could maybe add a column after the star rating and place a letters for their ship (Sh, Sp, etc.) But I dont really want to assume people's main ship when it's not obvious.

Rough - trades are not approved by caps and there is no universe where this trade would be considered grossly unfair for either side. Common sense is going to be used in deciding whether trades go through.

Well they are also saying that you shouldnt approve the trade you are in as op. Which makes sense. So that would leave the judging to me atm.

and... Skatarius has said his showrate is limited. Ricko is a question mark every twdt in my opinion, but so is bellflowers. Is a 10 terr who shows every week equal to a 10 spid who had limited showrate? No.
wb ratings are like even. Jav is in favor for tiny with Ricko and Skatarius.
bellflowers can multiship in base, ogron same. While Skatarius and Ricko are pure spids.

wb -/+, maybe a small + zid cuz ogron active and Ricko isnt.
jav + tiny
base ++ zidane
so yea, this trade is in favor for team zidane. Especially if you see what zidane will win by it and tiny wont, since his jav team is already looking good. His basing team doesnt get stronger by this trade.
i would personally reject this, but i guess zidane wont allow this as head op.

[zidane]

Sorry, colors are based on star rating otherwise it doesn't make sense for jav and wb. I could maybe add a column after the star rating and place a letters for their ship (Sh, Sp, etc.) But I dont really want to assume people's main ship when it's not obvious.

Rough - trades are not approved by caps and there is no universe where this trade would be considered grossly unfair for either side. Common sense is going to be used in deciding whether trades go through.

[ixt]

theres no denying that...ricko and skat are an enormous upgrade from claus and bell

[Rab]

It makes Tiny's base team stronger.

[Tiny]

Can we get colors on the team sheet for basers? terrs/sharks/spids etc..Also, could we get multi colors for multi shippers?...like hulk could be half green/blue...etc etc...Would reallllly help.

[Rough]

I'm not sure how an TWDT op can send a trade of his own and approve it immediately...I feel all trades needs to be reviewed by the remaining captains of each team. It is definitely questionable that these are all thunder buddies and tony has completely given up on his base team....it's whatsever

[ixt]

checking DTD at least...its both 9* and a 7* for a 9* for a 7*, so that checks out

[MHz]

The trade seems equal as long as Ricko and Skatarius are active. Let's hope Tiny has done his homework for the sake of his team.

[Rab]

I think this trade is about as balanced as trades get. If rejected it would have been like saying nobody can trade ever.

[zidane]

Dont really remember which trades were rejected last year but I do remember thinking the ra/beam one should have been 100% rejected.

It was a rd 3 + rd 7 for rd 1 (last pick) + rd 8.

Not sure which side you're saying is fishy but I definitely feel like I traded a lot and think its very debatable both on paper/in game.

[Dreamwin]

Ogron / Hoppin(Bell) for Ricko / Skatarius

I Accept

This is fishy on so many levels. But I dont care enough to argue + I would lose it anyway like I do every year.

I think pretty similar trade got rejected last year.

[zidane]

Wirah trade update for site. Also posted schedule in other thread and commodo had to squad name change to spider.

I will update sheets when home