TWDT 27 - Player ratings and discussion

[Dwopple]

Player ratings can be found here.

Feel free to discuss player ratings here and we will review prior to Sunday.

Edit: updated link to a new spreadsheet

[Tiny]

Ratings...

1) you can't have 1 10* jav. You have to bump everyone up .5 imo unless you dropping the * cap.

2) Jav Ratings

Jurassic - 8.5
Bombed - 9
Stayon - 9.5
Zizzo - 8
Aprix 8.5 - Went negative (17-25) as 8.5 and you raise him?
Rojo - 8
Hellkite 8.5
Bugy - 8.5 - You have wrong ratings, he wasnt a 7.5 last season


Borderline
Hellz - 8.5-9

More to come probably

[zidane]

agreed with tiny, jav could use some work

[Cape]

Hate to keep chiming in with negativity especially when I'm not playing.
But to add to Tiny's comment
Jz at 4k MMR rated 7.5
Cripple 4.3k MMR rated 8.

[Spezza]

OPINIONS FROM PUB:

WB - Tiny 8.5 Bombed 8.5 Viop - 7.5 Rage - 7.5 Ra -8 Zizu- never seen wb Hellkite 7.5 SNES - 6 (7?? rly??) Lee 7.5 bugyswartz - IDR Mark - 6.5 Joe 7 Avant 6 (pub warrior this guy needs playtime and he will ruin ur line at 6). Cripple is pretty sick when he tries.

JAV - probly shud lower cap or somethin. Bombed has 4669 MMR in dis one but 8.5? HMMMM. Stayon/Aprix same rating seems weird to me but w/e.

Base - Kassius 8, Racka 8 HK 9.5 Stayon 10 Groan 8.5 Banzi 7.5 Tiny 7.5 Olde 7.5 Renzi 9.5 Stayon 10 Autopilot 9.5 Hawk (?) Dutch baser 7.5

Hurricane has played well since returning too so his ratings are pretty sick. Bombed/HK ratings are very good value too. I'm pretty confident in the base ones I don't know if other ppl have other opinions.

[Jessup]

Can I be lowered to a 6 or 6.5 in base. My 7 star base rating is sort of ridiculous seeing as I play base only casually maybe 8 times a year and have never been on a twd basing squad. I mean a guy like cubone is a 7 and has a fairly extensive basing history and hangs out with basers constantly and he is a 7. There is no way we are equal basers. Also, since my mmr jav rating has been so bad and many say I am a detriment to my team(which is what ratings are based off of) I would appreciate my jav 7.5 being lowered to a 7. Thank you for the consideration.

[zidane]

already looks quite a bit better for jav. no lower caps plz since 6 team and rating inflation always way more significant than deflation

[Jz-]

Hate to keep chiming in with negativity especially when I'm not playing.
But to add to Tiny's comment
Jz at 4k MMR rated 7.5
Cripple 4.3k MMR rated 8.

yoo appreciate the call out but I absolutely should not be rated 8.5 for jav that is currently listed now. I was a 7 last season and couldnt even pull 1:1. MMR could be a directional indicator but I think players who don't have enough games to track should be taken as a grain of salt. I've got 70 games in jav so the uncertainly is fairly high compare to players who have 200+ games.

[Tiny]

WB - Tiny 8.5

Fake News

#30

Tiny

gryffindor

8

7

4

51

62

7

0.82

0.63

9

2

19

23

7

2

14%

38

side note...

Jav ratings do look much better, but I still think we need to address the 1 10* rating. In my opinion, i think we need the ratings to to be solid, which with the new adjustments have got us much closer to that, and then we need to upgrade every person .5. Imagine zidane wasnt here....we have to rate by the field...and if we dont have a 10* player, the 9.5's become the 10* players as that is the new norm. You can't rate people off of players that aren't participating. That or we have to change the *cap for that league individually, but i think that is the wrong thing to do. Typically you would take the amount of *s in that league and calculate how many teams could fill that * cap and make adjustments accordinly. I think at this point the jav field would be lower than the wb league, I could be wrong.

There is also the argument of what happens when ease/turban/steadman/best sign up late? (They will say they won't, but I am sure a couple of them will) Well they would get a .5 increase, aligning the field the way it should be. The only person who would benefit would be zidane, but he signed up on time...benefits.

[cubone]

yoo appreciate the call out but I absolutely should not be rated 8.5 for jav that is currently listed now. I was a 7 last season and couldnt even pull 1:1. MMR could be a directional indicator but I think players who don't have enough games to track should be taken as a grain of salt. I've got 70 games in jav so the uncertainly is fairly high compare to players who have 200+ games.

Don't let this guy pull the wool over your eyes. He's been absolutely killing it in MMR and if anything, might be a little low at 8.5.

[renzi]

Hurri 7.5 and Groan 7 in basing are some big questionable LOLs 🤡

[HellzNo!]

Product probably not 6.5 in jav?

[RageRitual]

Don't upgrade everyone just because there are limited 10* players, this ruins future seasons ratings from inflation. Just lower the *cap please. Basing for example felt a lot better last season due to ratings being brought down.

[Dreamwin]

I was the worst 8.5 wb last season and there were 10x 8* which had better stats than me. I havent gone 1:1 in multiple seasons. Jus throwing it out there.

[LeeRomeno]

I was the worst 8.5 wb last season and there were 10x 8* which had better stats than me. I havent gone 1:1 in multiple seasons. Jus throwing it out there.

i was 7* wb last season, got 7 mins of gametime entire league before subbed out, but apparently that is worth pumping me to 7.5. Before that had 0 gametime as 7* wb in 2 previous draft leagues. Does not make much sense.