[TW MAFIA] Doom of Westeros

[sdrawkcab]

I don't want to spam thread too bad but you're right hindsight is 20/20 but for real I'm concerned that you're just OK and FINE leaving a survivor around to fuck us in the ass at the end... a survivor in no way shape or form is pro town...

and I was speaking up then, you can go read two pages of me waving my arms begging to lynch the survivor lol

[the_paul]

SURVIVOR. IS. NOT. TOWN. AND. WILL. VOTE. WITH. SCUMTRAINS.

How will a survivor know who the scum is at this point, since PMing is illegal? You know who else votes on scum trains? Scum. You know who kills people at night? Scum. That's what I'm looking for. You trying to waste time and muddy the waters pushing for someone who is LITERALLY harmless at this point is mind boggling. By the way, town has the numbers advantage, so why would a survivor align themselves with scum on DAY 2?

[the_paul]

Also if we had lynched Jerome, who couldn't be bothered to post during the entire phase, much less vote during it, what would your criticism be? Got a lot of people who are popping up to criticize things with hindsight, if it was so obvious that Erias was a town cop while the phase was happening, why didn't anyone speak up then?

[sdrawkcab]

If you believe his survivor claim and think he was worth a day 2 lynch, then I really don't know what to tell you. What would we have learned from lynching Willby? What's the best case scenario? That we successfully lynch a survivor who publicly claimed on day 2? Unless you think Willby is brain dead and is scum who claimed fucking NIGHT KING on day 2, then lynching him would have done absolutely nothing for us.

Also if you think Exalt would have risked night killing Fis after he almost successfully helped get her lynched day 1, then you must also think he's brain dead. Maybe I'm guilty of giving these 2 too much credit, but I doubt it.

SURVIVOR. IS. NOT. TOWN. AND. WILL. VOTE. WITH. SCUMTRAINS.

[the_paul]

If you believe his survivor claim and think he was worth a day 2 lynch, then I really don't know what to tell you. What would we have learned from lynching Willby? What's the best case scenario? That we successfully lynch a survivor who publicly claimed on day 2? Unless you think Willby is brain dead and is scum who claimed fucking NIGHT KING on day 2, then lynching him would have done absolutely nothing for us.

Also if you think Exalt would have risked night killing Fis after he almost successfully helped get her lynched day 1, then you must also think he's brain dead. Maybe I'm guilty of giving these 2 too much credit, but I doubt it.

[sdrawkcab]

You act like we knew Erias was the cop and lynched him anyway. Erias made a post calling Exalt town, then voted on him, then disappeared. He made a total of like 4 posts in the entire game, and 1 came after he died. It's real easy to look after the fact and call everybody stupid, but what the hell did Erias do to warrant anybody trusting him? He didn't post at all, and also didn't even name claim which is definitely a scummy sign, and in addition made arguably the most asinine post in the thread trying to lynch someone he just said he thought was town?

Yes, it sucks that our 2 lynches have been a roleblocker and the town cop. Halp didnt even make an effort to defend himself outside of voting for the next closest person to be lynched, and Erias did literally nothing the entire game except try to lynch someone he said he thought was town.

The real problem with this game is that 25% of the people who signed up can't even give the bare minimum amount of a shit to post once in an entire phase, much less just once a day. Erias being the cop fucked us because he didn't give a shit enough to even be able to read the thread in the ~48 hours the phase went on. Field should be pissed because this setup seems like a lot of fun and obviously took a lot of effort. Off the top of my head Erias, inertube, and Jerome have all been completely, entirely worthless. Has inertube even posted yet? Jesus Christ

No, you're right we didn't know he was the cop. What we did we knew willby wasn't town, and after that was figured out you and exalt go off trying to "scum hunt" and lynch the cop. Scummiest shit I've ever seen. It was some real three stooges type shit. Guy claims not-town, you and exalt turn around and push a cop lynch

[the_paul]

Erias also called Voth a killer in the same sentence. Any reason why we shouldn't lynch Voth tomorrow, since this is apparently considered reasoning and evidence?

In a previous sentence* Jesus Christ

[the_paul]

"i bet he's a killer" come on guys

Erias also called Voth a killer in the same sentence. Any reason why we shouldn't lynch Voth tomorrow, since this is apparently considered reasoning and evidence?

[the_paul]

You act like we knew Erias was the cop and lynched him anyway. Erias made a post calling Exalt town, then voted on him, then disappeared. He made a total of like 4 posts in the entire game, and 1 came after he died. It's real easy to look after the fact and call everybody stupid, but what the hell did Erias do to warrant anybody trusting him? He didn't post at all, and also didn't even name claim which is definitely a scummy sign, and in addition made arguably the most asinine post in the thread trying to lynch someone he just said he thought was town?

Yes, it sucks that our 2 lynches have been a roleblocker and the town cop. Halp didnt even make an effort to defend himself outside of voting for the next closest person to be lynched, and Erias did literally nothing the entire game except try to lynch someone he said he thought was town.

The real problem with this game is that 25% of the people who signed up can't even give the bare minimum amount of a shit to post once in an entire phase, much less just once a day. Erias being the cop fucked us because he didn't give a shit enough to even be able to read the thread in the ~48 hours the phase went on. Field should be pissed because this setup seems like a lot of fun and obviously took a lot of effort. Off the top of my head Erias, inertube, and Jerome have all been completely, entirely worthless. Has inertube even posted yet? Jesus Christ

[sdrawkcab]

"i bet he's a killer" come on guys

[the_paul]

Hmm real hard for me to follow everything is going on, considering i dont know roles too well, and i'm new here.
So far i made some considerations, which are probably totally wrong but:

backwards, kthx, the_paul, fis voted Halp on day 1

Voth, Exalt, halp voted Fis on day 1

Halp was a townie, seems like Voth Exalt and Halp tried to save him? This moves em in the townie list.
In the night Fis got slayed, could be that either one of Voth or Exalt actually wanted him out so bad therefore killed him?

WillBy, Missa, the_paul, voth, kthx, rodney each went for a different person, this gives me no real clues.

I don't know this seems so messy to me lol, but I VOTE EXALT, i bet he's a killer and i like voth speeches.

Just to make things easier, here is the post Erias made to vote on Exalt

[sdrawkcab]

Backwards, you realize it was a vote between you and erias, right? Are you seriously mad we didnt lynch you instead?

I would've preferred we lynched LITERALLY ANYONE over the COP, YES. Everyone should be able to agree on that except scum... im up for lynching Exalt (exalt who our cop had his vote on D2, exalt who pushed everyone to lynch the cop) or willby (who claimed not-town in thread) D3 here and I'm not sure why anyone would disagree with both choices

[Exalt]

Backwards, you realize it was a vote between you and erias, right? Are you seriously mad we didnt lynch you instead?

[the_paul]

PLUS go look at who Erias had his vote on d2 you fucks

Yeah, on Exalt. We talked about it. Want to go find the post where Erias votes for Exalt and see the logic? It was one of the major reasons I was fine with voting for him.

[sdrawkcab]

PLUS go look at who Erias had his vote on d2 you fucks