Mafia 2020 #3: 14 Stories Above the Sea

[Voth]

X-shot ninja mafia poisoner - Willby does invent roles and get creative.

[Voth]

Could be an x-shot mafia poisoner. Poison kills can't be stopped by a bodyguard.

[the_paul]

Could be x-shot.

I understand that I am reaching here, but given Willby's prevalence for roles that are even/odd night and x-shot, this seems very likely to me. Also, the only other game I've seen poison involved in the last couple years was a Willby game, and it really fucked me up that game trying to figure out what the hell happened. 100% conjecture, but this is the most plausible theory to me.

[Edify]

Vote: Edify

Keep your seat, trash. Vote kthx.

Frankly I'd be fine voting for the_paul too because of the evidence from Vehicle. The inane combination of events necessary for T_p to be innocent is just ridiculous.

@_@

[kthx]

If we miss here its game over. I'm fine with TP or Edify.

[Edify]

One very important note, so as Kassius's flavor profession a bartender? I know he died behind the bar, but did he ever say anything about being Mark the Bartender? Like, for example, I am Johnie the Chef. This could be very important, I'm going to try to find this when my schedule breaks free a little bit, but if somebody knows the answer off top, hook me up

He never said it like that. He did give me beef for 'stealing his job' on one of the very early posts.

I made a theme flavored comment asking if anyone wanted their wine topped off.

He said something like "how could you steal my bartender job? I've been looking forward to it on the Leviathan all my life"

So that's how I knew he was Bartender. But I don't recall his giving a name.

[Voth]

Even if there is a ninja who killed exalt, it would have to be a ninja strongman to have avoided detection AND bypassed the bodyguard, which seems way overpowered, but I can’t see any other explanation.

Could be x-shot.

[the_paul]

Even if there is a ninja who killed exalt, it would have to be a ninja strongman to have avoided detection AND bypassed the bodyguard, which seems way overpowered, but I can’t see any other explanation.

Unless the ninja was sent night 1 with a poison modifier, since that reads how Exalt died. It would also explain why ixt wasn't killed in the attempt. I don't know the mechanics of how it played out, and I don't claim to understand it. I've told you guys why I was there night 2, that's the only part I understand. Also, the kill last night phase was done with bullets, which is definitely different than how Exalt was killed. I'll have to go back and look at the Jessup kill and see what happened there.

One very important note, so as Kassius's flavor profession a bartender? I know he died behind the bar, but did he ever say anything about being Mark the Bartender? Like, for example, I am Johnie the Chef. This could be very important, I'm going to try to find this when my schedule breaks free a little bit, but if somebody knows the answer off top, hook me up

[Halp]

Vote the_paul

[Halp]

I have no regrets on lynching ixt, he was the obvious choice. It was either Paul or IXT and ixt seemed scummier.

[Halp]

Even if there is a ninja who killed exalt, it would have to be a ninja strongman to have avoided detection AND bypassed the bodyguard, which seems way overpowered, but I can’t see any other explanation.

[Voth]

And if you look back through who orchestrated the ixt wagon I come to Halp, who multiple times steered the boat towards ixt and is now coming out to come for Paul first thing.

[Voth]

So Paul is not 100% guilty here.

It does boggle my mind that anyone would sacrifice their roleblocker Day 1 when he's an active player and you have an MIA teammate who may or may not end up modkilled. I just can't wrap my head around it.

[Voth]

Huh, there it is. A ninja. https://wiki.mafiascum.net/index.php?title=Ninja

[Voth]

Why isn’t Paul the obvious lynch here?

I read way back through the watcher stuff again and yeah, it appears Paul really is a mafia Strongman. Two people visited him, including the Bodyguard, and he died anyway. Weird since Paul did lynch out Backwards and that's quite a sacrifice. There is no role I know of that can kill someone at night without being detected by a Watcher - anyone know of one?

But if we do Paul today, Kthx should be next unless more evidence on someone else comes out.