Inc vs BC appeal - what was the point?

[Nimrook]

Eeks got a point there..

i dont get u have to recruit a guy cause dixy cant make it.. u break the rule.. u let an ineligible player play in the game tho u knew he couldnt play

[Sumpson]

so basingcrew knew putting lemar in would be illegal and yet still played him? I'd call that cheating...

Uhm no, like I said in my previous post.

And I'm not glad with the outcome of this either, I think there should be no punishment at all.

[Jeansi]

If the punishment is a 2 week ban from TWL, I don't see a reason as to why TWL playoff teams wouldn't recruit the best players from the teams that didn't make the playoffs. Ok so they could only play one game, but so what! B)

[Vehicle]

Obviously the game should be replayed considering the fact that if another player had been played in place of Lemar, the outcome of the game may have been different.

[Ivan]

1 - BasingCrew is too serious and I know it.

2 - Leroy is right.

3 - Lemar? - who cares about that shit.

4 - This year's league (TWL 8) definitely sucks.

[Jeansi]

Obviously the game should be replayed considering the fact that if another player had been played in place of Lemar, the outcome of the game may have been different.

They didn't have another player to put in instead of him. They would have played with 7.

[tahkis]

if another player had been played in place of Lemar

Tho they had only 8 players on, including Lemar. So as i stated earlier, 8v7 could have been a lot different game.

[Fourth]

The game shouldn't even be replayed, BC used a player that couldn't play this week, yes the guy deserved a 2 week ban from twl and should give Incuria the win.I dont know how they gave BC the win when they had a illegal player playing for them that match.

[Jeansi]

hehee beat you to it tahk :]

[Underground]

That is so stupid that only the player gets punishment. I guess if Venom makes playoffs and -f- doesnt (for example), they could recruit Koan to play that game. Venom would make it to semis (again, if they win) and only Koan would get to Not play the next 2 games .
Then in semi's they would recruit megaman (since Dice didnt make it) and same thing would happen.. Conclusion: Venom would win TWLB!

Seriously, please change that rule (if thats what it exactly says)

[demon girl]

That is so stupid that only the player gets punishment. I guess if Venom makes playoffs and -f- doesnt (for example), they could recruit Koan to play that game. Venom would make it to semis (again, if they win) and only Koan would get to Not play the next 2 games .
Then in semi's they would recruit megaman (since Dice didnt make it) and same thing would happen.. Conclusion: Venom would win TWLB!

Seriously, please change that rule (if thats what it exactly says)

Perhaps Twl roosters should be locked before playoffs to avoid such situations, dunno if that happens already but it would be a good measure to make the competition more fair.

[tahkis]

Well there is rule for that, 5.08 "All Trench Wars League rosters will experience a hard lock at the start of Round 6 matches. This means that no roster additions or substitutions will be allowed after that point".

[Underground]

Still, they wouldnt be able to play but the Host wont know in the beginning of the game since he has to talk to PL. Therefore the player will get to play and help his new team (squad#1) winning. After, the other squad (squad#2) appeals and the player is "banned" 2 weeks. Nothing happens to squad#1 that keeps the win making it trough the next phase!

[tahkis]

Hehe true.

[Nethila]

thanks for your concerns and inputs, I personally just went over some rules about TWL, and I will have a discussion with the other TWL Ops later tonight to work this out. THanks