TW Mafia 2020: TIGER KING - Murder, Mayhem, Madness

[kthx]

How could I be cult if your role was blocked last night? I'm confused? :laugh4:

I always thought living colour was overrated

[Halp]

Official Mid-Phase Vote Count:

Willby / 7 / Jessup, sdrawkcab, Zeebu, Voth, OverthinkingIt, Beast, Kthx
Voth / 5 / Party Falcon, the_paul, Vehicle, Kassius, WillBy

No vote / PoopCat, M_Leohnard

[Jessup]

I'm not sure if cult got to Jessup last night, that's borderline retarded.

How could I be cult if your role was blocked last night? I'm confused? :laugh4:

[PartyFalcon]

Lol yeah wait what

[kthx]

I'm not sure if cult got to Jessup last night, that's borderline retarded.

[Jessup]

Guys and gals, we could just lynch kthx still. he is for sure scum :laugh:

And yes I'm serious. I already explained how this immediate watcher claim 3 mins after phase ended with multiples casting votes on it could have been a preplanned ruse.

Mafia Watcher x shot The_Paul lol

wouldn't that be funny..

what if 4 people visited exalt lol and both willby and voth are innocent. ..and T_P and the strongman came at him. ROFL. I guess we are never going to be 100% sure here but often there is more than meets the eyes going on, All this is 100% relying on the_paul to be legit. Perhaps if we stall this train we can hold T_P's, willbys AND voths feet to fire and prove they are legit.

I know my idea will be scuffed at but sometimes in situations like this reshuffling is a good option.

Kthx been soooo scummy imo the entire game and it still walking around scot-free.

[WillBy]

Didn’t buy the psychiatrist claim. Still don’t.

But you're all about that jailkeeper/strongman claim?

[Zeebu]

What convinced you to vote for me in the first place?

Didn’t buy the psychiatrist claim. Still don’t.

[WillBy]

yep, and i would have swapped off of you to voth had anyone convinced me it was the way to go.

What convinced you to vote for me in the first place?

[Zeebu]

But you voted me way before either of those people showed up?

yep, and i would have swapped off of you to voth had anyone convinced me it was the way to go.

[Beast]

I really have nothing useful to add yet. You guys have posted 50 pages in the first two phases. I can post bullshit like the rest of you if that's "being active". I am town, my modifier mentions if there is a cult. Imho that line as part of my modifier is more important information than my role itself. Someone saw 2 people visit the dead guy last night let's lynch one end of story.

We got lucky last night with the watcher, Let cop do some work and we will have more to go on soon.

interesting... this has me believe that there is a third party, otherwise why would halp mention "IF there is a cult" in the descriptions :/

[WillBy]

bit snippy there.

the math says to vote you first since i think theres a correlation between you, kass and PF. voting voth first delays that by a day.

all scenerios point towards lynching the person left between you and voth if the person lynched the first day flips town.

But you voted me way before either of those people showed up?

[sdrawkcab]

Sorry my modifier mentions IF there is a cult*

[sdrawkcab]

I really have nothing useful to add yet. You guys have posted 50 pages in the first two phases. I can post bullshit like the rest of you if that's "being active". I am town, my modifier mentions if there is a cult. Imho that line as part of my modifier is more important information than my role itself. Someone saw 2 people visit the dead guy last night let's lynch one end of story.

We got lucky last night with the watcher, Let cop do some work and we will have more to go on soon.

[Voth]

To be clear, I’m not defending willby. I’m more of a conspiracy theorist when it comes to these things (see my pic), AFAIK you’re all scum and you’re all trying to kill me and I can’t trust anyone except Jessup, Scarlet, and Exalt—but none of those people have access to superior information, so I can’t fully trust any information I’m getting from anyone. I’ll trust The_Paul slightly more after one of Voth / willby flip a killing role, but it’s certainly possible that both Voth and willby are scum (I too include SK’s as scum—anyone without a town win condition to me is scum. Yes even neutral survivors, see Kass’s layup for a mafia victory last game at lylo), and it’s also possible that the_paul is scum.

I didn’t think this fodder would be useful (since anyone who’s played more than a few times knows that this is the mindset every townie /should/ be in to avoid getting duped) so I kept my opinion relatively short, and voted for voth at the beginning of the phase when there were already votes following the_paul on willby. My concern was, as I articulated, that Voth was part of the mafia—as I said then and again now, it was really only a hunch, and a don’t trust willby either.

Im hoping that by explaining all of this it may encourage some of the less vocal players to share their thoughts between Voth and willby without feeling like they’re going to get dragged through the mud for it. I don’t think it’s helpful to use this day phase to badger everyone currently voting for voth or willby and threaten to lynch them for being scum if they don’t change their vote from one to the other—EITHER ONE IS A PERFECTLY FINE LYNCH FROM THE PERSPECTIVE OF A TOWNIE WHO IS ONLY RELYING ON HUNCHES. So if you have some authoritative reason to believe one is a better lynch than the other, I think you’re either: (1) mafia and know what’s up, (2) you’re one of those two ppl, sorry budds, (3) you’re a town PR with information which is cool and part of why I don’t think we should be badgering people who are voting for one over the other DURING THIS DAY PHASE, (4) you’re making assumptions and you don’t actually have an authoritative reason, you only think you do.

so, in short, I will not be badgered out of my vote. I very well may change it since phase change isn’t for over 24 hours—but it won’t be from being

A very long post to say one thing:

I was entirely useless until my scum buddy Willby was on the chopping block, but I'm here now. Voth is not mafia but he is scum because that includes third party. He is not on my scum team so must be third party scum.

Anyone remember when I posted twice in forty pages about emojis and how both voth and Willby are not "logicking" right? I now unequivocally know voth is the "scum" (AKA third party because I'm actual scum) that we are looking for.

----

It was great breaking down your post for you, but next time it would be great if you say it yourself before page 40 and your scum buddy is one of two on the chopping block.