Trench Wars New Theme Feedback!

[Xog]

[Twerp]

I think the likes/dislikes is a little too big after each post. Maybe make it so that only one bar is present.

thx! Likes/Dislikes What do you think of the above post?: [+1 Like this post] [-1 Dislike this post]

I'm digging the new style though. Definitely like the gray. Just turn up your monitor brightness a bit.

[Wax]

Nice job, fellas.

[Rogue]

The whole theme seems kinda old school but its str8 though.

[Crescent Seal]

:ship1:


spent 5 minutes writing out 'cres' with the warbird gif only to see this

You have included 42 images in your message. You are limited to using 5 images so please go back and correct the problem and then continue again.

[Edify]

The new stuff looks great! My only complaint is that the Likes/Dislikes thing adds on extra space onto every single post, which can get pretty long. Maybe there's a setting for that.

[Dant-Zu]

Don't like the like/dislike thing. I think it's pretty useless and takes too much space. Also I think the message space is too narrow. Therefore I changed back to old theme.

[soup]

I agree with edify and the skin is ugly as hell.

[Fluffz]

all the whitetext is visible, what were you thinking?!

[M_M God]

Keep the feedback coming guys, we will try to implement any feedback we get, as long as it's doable ofcourse

[M_M God]

can u put the like/dislike buttons in the same box as the post
u know, so we dont have an extra football field to scroll past and stuff

Done, but if someone likes/dislikes your post it will still show under your post. Will see if we can put that on one line to minimize the space it uses.

[Jason]

dant-zu, could you elaborate please? i don't understand what you mean by "the message space" when you refer to it being too narrow.

cambia, when you say "action buttons" do you mean buttons such as reply to thread or post new thread? those can be changed quite easily. i could, at the very least, make them brighter.

i agree with everyone saying that like/dislike takes up too much space. this was an issue we discussed during testing. the actual like/dislike buttons can be moved up into the post box itself, and i see m_m has already done this. only the listings now show under the post. i will have to fix the styling again though, and i think i'll play around with it a bit and put everything on one line as twerp suggested. that damn add-on is such a pain.

as for the header graphic, i'll have some time tomorrow to play around. i'll see about adding a space background as opposed to the current one.

i will also see about re-enabling darkness for you, ilya. edit: looks like someone already did this.

i have a lot of shit going on today, so i won't get to any of this stuff until tomorrow, but as promised, we will listen to your feedback and try our best to whip this skin into shape for you.

[Jason]

oh, and about the smilies...

smilies are a bitch, plain and simple. all of the old smilies do not work on a dark background. you see ugly white halo effects. the new batch of smilies work on both light and dark backgrounds. however, the new batch is by no means set in stone. we just threw together some smilies so we had a few for the launch of the skin.

after a majority of the usability tweaks have been taken care of and we have addressed your feedback concerns, smilies will be my next project.

i really like that add-on you discussed, xog. will have to see about getting that going for us.

[Jason]

as discussed in the feedback thread, i will work on the likes/dislikes when i have some time tomorrow. i agree that it takes up too much space. it'll take a little screwing around with the template, but i think i can get it to show all likes/dislikes on one line, and i might be able to incorporate it into the post box itself, as the buttons are now.

btw, gonna merge this thread with the feedback thread so i don't have to keep checking two threads.

[Jason]

thread merged with official feedback thread