TWDT Season 22 Trading Thread

[Poseidon]

meh, Rough and Ra are potentially overvalued in every category plus are hardly active whereas bombed has 80+ rounds combined in jd and dd since the reset - prob 80x more than rough and ra combined. hes the best dueler in eg history we are told and is obv improving p rapidly. and in twdd guys putting up numbers that look more like a 9* at least when not having to play with lobsters like jessup j-b-dink jamal and jarjarbinks. plus fuk ur stats at any rate, i know what i see and come playoffs the guy will prob be playing a 9* level in wb if not already and 8* in jav. 2+ whole fkn stars of value between the two leagues - YUGE. whereas u could argue rough and ra combined are -2.5* value between all leagues - a potential +4.5 star differential in Dwopples favor - FKN YYUuGEEE. of course im leaving out the point that BOMBED is overvalued in base, but the reality as i see it is the guy doesn't have a spot in the line on either of these basing teams, nor do rough and ra except as subs: HYPE is too topheavy and I highlighted the problem with the UK25 line in the PR. and if GA were to bench Cape-spider in favor of any of these 3 he is a fkn clueless baser and captain. botched ratings galore, par for the course.

it's not as bad of a trade as is being made out to be. the focus needs be on the VALUE and not if this were a trade in TWL or an uncapped league; given the extreme reactions ud think we have no star caps this twdt. beast shouldn't be included, 6 and 6.5* who aren't completely clueless always have some value. howev, if this was a straight up Ra and Rough for BOMBED, giving Dwopple a potential +4.5 star net gain in value, i would certainly approve the trade if i were making the call.

and as is usually the case these days the man ends with a giant

*SHRUG*

[Iron]

I nominate Dwopple and Golden_Aim to CoTW (Crackheads of The Week) - Wirah, can you donate 20 buckaroos to these guys so that they can fuel their crack addiction and post more fun trades?

LOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOL dying

[Dwopple]

You guys who don't bother to look into the numbers & why certain players were offered, but instead offer your opinions are hilarious. GA needed low *s to fill his jav and base line, of which I have 5+ possible pieces. The trade was Rough + Ra + fillers for bombed. BUT OH NO, THAT'S PREPOSTEROUS!

I clearly have the cap space for a trade like this, but I understand the optics of it. SEE YOU FOOLS SUNDAY 8.5.2

[Rab]

The problem is the retrade value of the players. Nobody doubts that you think this trade would be beneficial for your team.

[Tiny]

there are easy ways around this, you just have to try harder. Offer inactive players or people you don't use to bridge the gap of retardation in this trade.

[Tiny]

The problem is the retrade value of the players. Nobody doubts that you think this trade would be beneficial for your team.

agreed

[Dwopple]

I'll pretend like you all know the exact dynamics of this trade, the risk of each player involved, and the risk tolerance for both captains and just say thank you all for your trade guidance.

Like I said, I understand the optics of this trade. It was a gamble GA and myself were both willing to take given my extra cap space, his twdt needs, and given the dynamics of the players involved in this trade. I'm also fine with it not going through after speaking with Rough.

You guys are like the space paparazzi spewing speculation and opinions for enjoyment.

I'm kidding, we've all been doing that here for a decade+.

[beam]

I'll pretend like you all know the exact dynamics of this trade, the risk of each player involved, and the risk tolerance for both captains and just say thank you all for your trade guidance.

from a straight team improvement aspect id say bombed improves your team more than the other 4 guys combined improve ga's team especially if rough is going to be missing as many games as he said he will but as stated above the players do have their own individual market value that has to be considered

my advice would be to either resubmit ra/rough for bombed as a 2 for 1 or add some random garbage players from the bottom of your roster to make it maybe a 3 for 4 so it just looks better and i cant see it getting denied

[Dwopple]

Thank you beam for repeating what nobody else has already said

[Poseidon]

yes will add i am uncertain of the precedent or standard when it comes to qualifying trades & how much the league wants to consider "market value" or the fairness of the trade to the league as a whole in addition to the two teams themselves ... i would personally lean towards neglecting the whole of the league and only focusing on what is fair between the two trading teams as it seems it would make for more exciting trading and etc throughout the season, w captains more able to strategically trade straight up for market value, tho mayb the league has experienced this and feels it should be the other way, i dunno. regardless bombed is def a substantial + in value relative to the ratings of rough and ra in 2 of the 3 leagues

[Omega Red]

Why are we (normal rank and file players) allowed to post in this thread? Seems not ideal allowing people to voice their opinions on proposed trades. It could possibly influence Op decisions I think

[WillBy]

Why are we (normal rank and file players) allowed to post in this thread? Seems not ideal allowing people to voice their opinions on proposed trades. It could possibly influence Op decisions I think

Forums arent sophisticated enough to make it easy to restrict general players from posting, and I dont much care to restrict speech about trades. If anything begins to water down the thread too much, I may step in, but as this is a community run game/zone/league, i like having some community input.

[Dwopple]

HYPE! trades Rough, Ra, and Cyclone to Unknown25 for BOMBED, bellf, and hellrazor

[Golden_Aim]

HYPE! trades Rough, Ra, and Cyclone to Unknown25 for BOMBED, bellf, and hellrazor

ok willby, u rdy?


Edit: Rough telling the truth, I deny this trade ant it *won't happen*

[Vys]

Lifeban will trade trasher for ardour and omega red with prayer