Mafia 2020: Town of Salem

[ixt]

new time has been set

[PartyFalcon]

Ok, I'll offer some info. I took a protective action last night. Did anyone else? If not, we know I was targetted.

I disagree that we can draw that inference (that you were targeted) EVEN IF we could confirm that your reported protective action was the only one, and I therefore also disagree that power roles should out themselves for the purported purpose of attempting to support or refute that inference.

Why I think we cannot draw your proposed inference:
EVEN IF you were the only protective action last night, scum could have abstained (this is often a good strategy specifically because it sews discord and confusion, which is anti-town). Another reason why we can’t make your proposed inference EVEN IF you were the only protective action last night is they could have targeted someone like a commuter, or scum could take multiple phases to kill such as by poison or arson, in which case we wouldn’t know until tomorrow morning.

[Jessup]

Ok, I'll offer some info. I took a protective action last night. Did anyone else? If not, we know I was targetted.

not too snoop too much but who did you protect? You saying you have a protective role?

[Kassius]

I disagree that we can draw that inference (that you were targeted) EVEN IF we could confirm that your reported protective action was the only one, and I therefore also disagree that power roles should out themselves for the purported purpose of attempting to support or refute that inference.

Why I think we cannot draw your proposed inference:
EVEN IF you were the only protective action last night, scum could have abstained (this is often a good strategy specifically because it sews discord and confusion, which is anti-town). Another reason why we can’t make your proposed inference EVEN IF you were the only protective action last night is they could have targeted someone like a commuter, or scum could take multiple phases to kill such as by poison or arson, in which case we wouldn’t know until tomorrow morning.

I very much doubt that scum won't take the opportunity to night kill at this stage. We've killed 2 commuters/bus drivers already, I also doubt there'll be any more.

If no-one else can offer up who they protected, then I know at least I was targetted.

[Kassius]

not too snoop too much but who did you protect? You saying you have a protective role?

I protected myself, sorry for being unclear.

[kthx]

I'm assuming since the RB is dead and Exalt alive this proves willby's claim. I'm thinking Jessup is town this game also no idea why him and willby have been fighting nonstop after Jessup might have saved the game for us with his train on backwards. Who did you protect by the way willby?

[Jessup]

oh ok nice move kass $$ thx for being up front too! Very town of you I must say..

[WillBy]

not too snoop too much but who did you protect? You saying you have a protective role?

Sure seems like he said he protected himself, given that he think he might've been targeted. Sounds like he might be claiming survivor? That's a mainly anti town role btw.

Exalt is still alive, can we stop saying im a poisoner?

Looking forward to hearing what Beast has to say.

For now, I'll return to my vote Jessup. Last time I trusted my gut we lynched scum. Might as well go for it again.

[kthx]

Sure seems like he said he protected himself, given that he think he might've been targeted. Sounds like he might be claiming survivor? That's a mainly anti town role btw.

Exalt is still alive, can we stop saying im a poisoner?

Looking forward to hearing what Beast has to say.

For now, I'll return to my vote Jessup. Last time I trusted my gut we lynched scum. Might as well go for it again.

I'm pretty sure that you are wrong here willby, he lead that lynch that got us one mafia on that double lynch. I'm leaning towards PF over him honestly.

[Kassius]

Sure seems like he said he protected himself, given that he think he might've been targeted. Sounds like he might be claiming survivor? That's a mainly anti town role btw.

Exalt is still alive, can we stop saying im a poisoner?

Looking forward to hearing what Beast has to say.

For now, I'll return to my vote Jessup. Last time I trusted my gut we lynched scum. Might as well go for it again.

Jessup doesn't read scum to me at all. Even more so with his question above. That's too nuanced imho.And why vote Jessup on a hunch when you've seemingly got a non-town read on me to another faction?

And at the risk of sounding like a broken record, poisoner isn't the only delay-kill role, you're still not confirmed as a doctor. You haven't claimed that you protected anyone last night? You could have doused 2 people in gasoline these past 2 nights, you could have infected 2 people with plague, made some vampires, done all sorts.

You're reading even more scum to me than before.

Was anyone watching Willby last night?

[Kassius]

I'm assuming since the RB is dead and Exalt alive this proves willby's claim. I'm thinking Jessup is town this game also no idea why him and willby have been fighting nonstop after Jessup might have saved the game for us with his train on backwards. Who did you protect by the way willby?

Am I the only one looking at the roles in the Town of Salem wiki ? :furious2:

[WillBy]

I'm pretty sure that you are wrong here willby, he lead that lynch that got us one mafia on that double lynch. I'm leaning towards PF over him honestly.

I wouldnt say he led the lynch. Beast was the first to vote sdraw, jessup asked him not to but then joined him? Voth voted out of self defense, then i (followed by paul) yoloed to save voth/salvage dumb lynch.

Beast You shud unvote too beast.. no reason to have a solo vote as the one confirmed townie.. well the one more confirmed than anyone else we shud say.

I think jessup thought this was a safe place to stash his vote, which changed dramatically when 3 others joined.

[kthx]

Am I the only one looking at the roles in the Town of Salem wiki ? :furious2:

Care to elaborate? I used to play TOS so I don't know what you mean here? You talking an arsonist/poisoner action informs the target that they are poisoned or soaked?

[kthx]

I wouldnt say he led the lynch. Beast was the first to vote sdraw, jessup asked him not to but then joined him? Voth voted out of self defense, then i (followed by paul) yoloed to save voth/salvage dumb lynch.



I think jessup thought this was a safe place to stash his vote, which changed dramatically when 3 others joined.

I think you are missing something though. Jessup said he left an "easter egg" in the pms he sent and then made a post with only "click click" after that a few people jumped on the backwards vote train. I'm assuming he might have a daytime role of some sort and that was the very unsubtle secret message

[Jessup]

I wouldnt say he led the lynch. Beast was the first to vote sdraw, jessup asked him not to but then joined him? Voth voted out of self defense, then i (followed by paul) yoloed to save voth/salvage dumb lynch.



I think jessup thought this was a safe place to stash his vote, which changed dramatically when 3 others joined.

Willby, First, I could gave sat unvoted and waited. I moved quickly on a mafioso who already had a vote on him by the most confirmed townie in the group. If I was scum I'd have waited to see where votes fall or if I voted quickly would have thrown it on a townie. Makes no sense at all. Plus I could have unvoted backwards and gone to voth at any point and time to stop the double lynch.

Second, you do realize now with kass saying he has a protective role it has cast MUCH more doubt on your doctor claim. I'm smelling whiffs of scum yet again on you is all I gotta say.. peeyewww