TW Mafia: Still Worthy

[Jessup]

Oh and I didn't use my defensive shot power either and will tonight.

[Jessup]

Figure it out, my vote is firm

[the_paul]

And you wonder why people make fun of how you play. Jesus

[Voth]

I am pretty sure the only reason that Paul has not rolled over yet is because he wants another night phase so he can bullshit a claim that Halp is scum, his investigation said so.

I think now Jessup is the last scum along with Paul and Backwards. Rodney came up with a pro town idea for the two trains to be the two assumed scum.

By the way Jessup, you are literally horrible at this game even with Paul coaching you.

[Voth]

Pauls posts are long winded and full of hot air. He keeps repeating his same points but not actually addressing the reasons Exalt has given that directly implicate him as scum. He is dancing, and looking good doing it, but I know that dance bro... it is the scum dance.

[the_paul]

I am pretty sure the only reason that Paul has not rolled over yet is because he wants another night phase so he can bullshit a claim that Halp is scum, his investigation said so.

I think now Jessup is the last scum along with Paul and Backwards. Rodney came up with a pro town idea for the two trains to be the two assumed scum.

By the way Jessup, you are literally horrible at this game even with Paul coaching you.

I'm not coaching him, I would fucking quit.

Still waiting for any evidence that I'm scum. 3 people (notice the number) keep accusing me but they seem to be having trouble finding actual reasons why, or problems with my logic

[the_paul]

Pauls posts are long winded and full of hot air. He keeps repeating his same points but not actually addressing the reasons Exalt has given that directly implicate him as scum. He is dancing, and looking good doing it, but I know that dance bro... it is the scum dance.

He hasn't given a single reason outside of deliberately misreading my post and immediately being proven wrong. My posts are long because you 3 keep acting like Exalt nailed me and I'm not saying anything. Not one person has found a hole in my logic, despite you 3 trying to characterize it as such.

Getting off work, see you guys in a couple hours.

[Voth]

I'm not coaching him, I would fucking quit.

Still waiting for any evidence that I'm scum. 3 people (notice the number) keep accusing me but they seem to be having trouble finding actual reasons why, or problems with my logic

1. I believe Halp.
2. Knowing I am town means both you and Backwards are scum. Your bullshit claim makes you the first to go.
3. I believe Exalt, and your bullshit roleclaim I do not buy for the exact reasons he stated.
4. Field made a good point too, you have been a groupie all game. I need to watch you closer because you are a good scum player and I overlook you a lot. Nice playing before that claim.

[Voth]

And, I know you actually hate playing with Jessup because virtually everyone does, but the distancing is obvious.

[the_paul]

1. I believe Halp.
2. Knowing I am town means both you and Backwards are scum. Your bullshit claim makes you the first to go.
3. I believe Exalt, and your bullshit roleclaim I do not buy for the exact reasons he stated.
4. Field made a good point too, you have been a groupie all game. I need to watch you closer because you are a good scum player and I overlook you a lot. Nice playing before that claim.

You understand that if I am telling the truth about my role and results, there is absolutely an avenue where you are town and backwards is scum? I?m not saying it?s definitively you, it?s 50:50.

So it all boils down to you believing in tracker/watcher/sensor or tracker/sensor/cop? That?s fine if that?s what you?re saying, I absolutely disagree but it?s a reason at least.

I have definitely been a groupie. I only got innocent results and fucking Jessup told everybody my name before night 1. Maybe it?s because I already knew my role or because I?m a nerd, but I thought it would immediately be obvious that Nick fury would be an investigative role. I have no idea how nobody forced me to claim despite my name being out there, especially since (flavorful narrative alert) Fury has a complicated relationship in the series with the good guys.

As a side note, I don?t really know backwards at all, but if the mafia is really Exalt/Voth/Rodney, I?ll be jealous as fuck. Granted I got Rodney killed last time we were mafia buddies, but we had to deal with BIET and an afk godfather. But damn, if that?s the team, fuck you guys I?m jealous, that?s a hell of a group

[Jessup]

I'm giving T_P the benefit of the doubt as he early on was honest about his identity being different and not a super hero. I would see ZERO reason a mafia would do that publicly as if all of them were non super heros they would 100% say do NOT reveal this fact.

T_P should get a pass. Voth is the one to go for.

[the_paul]

I have to get a quick nerd rant in, this doesn't have anything to do with the game or theories, so feel free to skip this.

I understand this game is extra nerdy. We are managing to be some of the nerdiest people on a message board for a 20 year old fucking spaceship game. I get it. But I've actually put some serious effort into this game. I phoned last game in after a 5 day day 1 phase, and I played like absolute horseshit, so I probably deserve this. But Willby, who I have a ton of respect for, went above and beyond with this game setup. He's obviously very busy, but he hasn't stopped hosting or anything. Exalt and I yell at each other a lot in these games, but we're also very rarely on the same side. Our disagreements start and end in the game, and I have a ton of respect for him as an accomplished mafia player (he could legitimately hate me, so this could only apply to my side). I don't think I need to elaborate on my recently kindled bromance with Voth and my respect for him. I'm a huge Rodney fan, we were spaceship friends years ago and he's a great mafia player too, I enjoy playing with him. Its pretty obvious that at least some of us are on opposite sides, and I'm going to go out of my way to get them lynched and win for town, but whoever the mafia turns out to be has played a great game and its been a lot of fun thus far.

That being said, if Jessup follows through with what he said, that's a seriously chicken shit move and I would not be opposed to a suspension from mafia. This and next day phase are the do or die time, and this clown has tapped out of this phase a full 36ish? hours early. That's a bitch made move, through and through. I feel like I've made my points clearly and presented my case well, and I appreciate those of you who read them all, even if you obviously disagree. But backwards is already asking for tl;dr's of posts despite having 36ish hours to read through, Field has already said he'll be very limited until Friday (I get it life happens, not his fault), Jessup has thrown a temper tantrum and walked off. Halp and Backwards have been great to play with, but it sucks this game went from being an instant classic to having 40%ish of the survivors being borderline non participants.

I guess my point is, Voth, Rodney, Exalt, backwards, halp: I believe all of the mafia are in this group, but whoever you are you've played a great game and its been a lot of fun up to this point. Willby, this game has been everything it was advertised to be and then some. I just wanted to thank you guys because these last few games have been a much needed distraction for me over the last month or two.

This is the nerdiest rant I've ever made, I expect to be made fun of for it, I'm just annoyed that this game is shaping up to have a hollow ending because of a combination of fuck fuck morons and people having legitimate irl demands, despite the fact that it was shaping up to be one of the best games in recent times.

Rant over, lets get back to hating each other. Lynch Exalt tomorrow!!!

[the_paul]

I'm giving T_P the benefit of the doubt as he early on was honest about his identity being different and not a super hero. I would see ZERO reason a mafia would do that publicly as if all of them were non super heros they would 100% say do NOT reveal this fact.

T_P should get a pass. Voth is the one to go for.

I appreciate the support. I appreciate even more that you're participating. True to how you normally play, your post comes as I'm writing a fucking essay blasting you for walking off, but I'm really glad you seem to be participating. Again, I'm glad you believe me, but Voth is the wrong move. I strongly suspect he is the Godfather between him and backwards, but it is a 50:50 shot and anything else is just acting on hunches. If you do believe me, Exalt is the closest thing to a sure thing that I can offer. If we do no lynch, and I guess if mafia doesn't have a roleblocker which I hadn't considered until now somehow, I'm confident I can offer a legitimate guilty result tomorrow just in time for town to win.

[RoDNeY]

I have to get a quick nerd rant in, this doesn't have anything to do with the game or theories, so feel free to skip this.

I understand this game is extra nerdy. We are managing to be some of the nerdiest people on a message board for a 20 year old fucking spaceship game. I get it. But I've actually put some serious effort into this game. I phoned last game in after a 5 day day 1 phase, and I played like absolute horseshit, so I probably deserve this. But Willby, who I have a ton of respect for, went above and beyond with this game setup. He's obviously very busy, but he hasn't stopped hosting or anything. Exalt and I yell at each other a lot in these games, but we're also very rarely on the same side. Our disagreements start and end in the game, and I have a ton of respect for him as an accomplished mafia player (he could legitimately hate me, so this could only apply to my side). I don't think I need to elaborate on my recently kindled bromance with Voth and my respect for him. I'm a huge Rodney fan, we were spaceship friends years ago and he's a great mafia player too, I enjoy playing with him. Its pretty obvious that at least some of us are on opposite sides, and I'm going to go out of my way to get them lynched and win for town, but whoever the mafia turns out to be has played a great game and its been a lot of fun thus far.

That being said, if Jessup follows through with what he said, that's a seriously chicken shit move and I would not be opposed to a suspension from mafia. This and next day phase are the do or die time, and this clown has tapped out of this phase a full 36ish? hours early. That's a bitch made move, through and through. I feel like I've made my points clearly and presented my case well, and I appreciate those of you who read them all, even if you obviously disagree. But backwards is already asking for tl;dr's of posts despite having 36ish hours to read through, Field has already said he'll be very limited until Friday (I get it life happens, not his fault), Jessup has thrown a temper tantrum and walked off. Halp and Backwards have been great to play with, but it sucks this game went from being an instant classic to having 40%ish of the survivors being borderline non participants.

I guess my point is, Voth, Rodney, Exalt, backwards, halp: I believe all of the mafia are in this group, but whoever you are you've played a great game and its been a lot of fun up to this point. Willby, this game has been everything it was advertised to be and then some. I just wanted to thank you guys because these last few games have been a much needed distraction for me over the last month or two.

This is the nerdiest rant I've ever made, I expect to be made fun of for it, I'm just annoyed that this game is shaping up to have a hollow ending because of a combination of fuck fuck morons and people having legitimate irl demands, despite the fact that it was shaping up to be one of the best games in recent times.

Rant over, lets get back to hating each other. Lynch Exalt tomorrow!!!

Everything aside i would like to agree with you here. I've always loved Willby games so seeing everyone come together on this one was amazing to be a part of. Mafia games yeah are probably the nerdiest thing we can do here and you can tell we all have a passion for it. Regardless of what we say to each other in each game i have a massive amount of respect for you all when it comes to mafia games. I respect you all as Hosts, teammates and i respect you as enemies when we have to play against one another.

I do believe that Paul is scum at this point but at the same time id also like to say that scum has played a great game so far. Paul didnt appear on any scum list until today, all of scum have managed to hide under the radar in lynches and push us to lynch townies in great fashion. Granted those townies didnt really help themselves but thats neither here nor there.

I love you all but ill never trust a goddamn one you either

[sdrawkcab]

Driving home now will try to read up in an hour.. plz stop posting essays ty