Forum Mafia - Shawshank Redemption - Salvation lies within

[Voth]

To be clear, I only got up to the field post I quoted so far and I am taking care of two kids alone right now, so bear with me. This may take a while to catch up and respond or not happen at all before phase change, but I will scour the thread to check vote count for sure.

[Exalt]

When I read his claim this was my EXACT thought. My PM says nothing about "town." I obviously am not on a scum chat and have no recruitment abilities so I know I'm town, not scum or third party.

A ton to catch up on but this stuck out because I thought the exact same thing. Vehicle is scum.

Ditto actually. Nothing about town in my role pm. It's just 'you are this person, this job at shawshank, here are your abilities' type thing.

[WillBy]

Siding with them? Who am I siding with? And I still think you're scum, but am willing to entertain the idea that I'm wrong.

Leo and beast are 2 of the other 3 voting me. They could be bussing me sure, but it doesnt seem very necessary at this point, does it?

But besides that, what is the the downside to tying votes between me and leo? Are you worried that things will be easier to swing to Halp?

[Jessup]

I'll vote with willby and zeebu this phase if need be.. . they have more truth revealed in claims than any1 else.. I still feel field is the pressure vote train we need to force a reveal tho and at same time confirm voth..still if I have to go with someone those two have the most real info backing up their claims.

As it is we have a few pairings we can learn from if we push a train on either of these duos. Best duos to go after if we want to confirm a townie. (against willby/zebu or kass/ exalt today tho)

Voth and Field (best for town to nip in the bud ASAP) Neither even have to die but now it is too late and scum very possibly have refused my logic over and over on this out of fear.. literally feel ignored when there is complete logic behind it. The only thing voth has going for him is a flavor claim.. everything else points to voth being scum.

Willby and Zeebu

Kassius and Exalt (lesser degree but after kass claimed exalt was totally in kass' corner)

[WillBy]

I personally don't prefer PF, because they don't help my process of elimination. Mleo and Halp do. If those flip red, the game should be easy to solve going forward. If they don't, then Scarlet was my next choice as scum. If I have to repost the entire sequence of events where I got this whole thought process from, I can. After I mentioned that whole thing, Scarlet disappeared too. I kind of want to resolve that.

Why is everyone against mleo/halp?

I'd like y'all to just pick one lol.

[Exalt]

Also, regarding Scarlet being scum, I'd be saying Vehicle was one of their scum buddies if so. This has to do with Scarlet taking hard TR stances on WillBy/Zeebu, started to do so with Vehicle, but when pressed due to TRing almost all the possible names on the PoE list, they started to waiver on Vehicle and just made an excuse that they want town to lynch mleo/halp first. That whole idea was me giving out names in my PoE and saying to everyone 'lynch these two seperate people or no lynch' and seeing what everyone said. Field got 'cleared' by Voth. Zeebu got 'cleared' through WillBy. Etc. I needed stances from people on all the names too, so that when someone flips red, we can catch the others through association.

The D1 VC is pretty telling imo about who is teamed with who. Scarlet was the only wagon on D1 to really move when there was like a 4-way tie. I doubt scum would be voting each other out on D1, since not everyone is Paul, so that's something to consider.

Anyway, I'm okay with lynching Vehicle over WillBy if it comes down to it. If he flips red, I'm going after Scarlet next.

[Exalt]

If you’re going with a “lynch the lurkers” approach, you’ve got a lot of options that make more sense than me. I’ve got more posts this game than at least 4 other people. I’ve called out the players I think are scum, and I have no other information to provide on this day.

Exalt , if you’re even capable of reading other people’s opinions, go back and read my posts and tell me what you disagree with? Where’s the scum slip? Or is post counting your version of scum hunting?

Were you planning on actually doing anything this game, or do you just want to complain that I find you scummy instead? I don't care who has more posts. You've done nothing with the posts you do have. Who do you think is scum this game?

[Jessup]

I find vehicles claim as "asshole" believable because its a kthx game and its a role kthx wud make lol.. Halp has made a few posts relating to game too. M_leo did too. Honestly for me halp and m_leoare not too scummy seeming.

PF is honestly the one I worry most about as a lurker atm. She did this with werewolf too, blaming her busy schedule and then pounced. She is a good player too so I have a few reservations also voting her but the danger she poses as scum is just as worrisome.. I could do a PF vote

[Vehicle]

Oh wow, pardon me, I said Town Asshole instead of Prison Asshole.

Voth and Field low-key trying to start a bandwagon on me because I said "town" instead of "prison" coupled with the fact that the only reason we're not voting Field is because Voth came out of the woodwork to declare him innocent. Their shade towards me is the flimsiest reasoning in this thread and I can already see around the bend to what they're trying to cook up.

It's a big move because it means you're both dead when Field flips scum, but I now believe it.

Unvote WIllby
Vote Field

You guys gotta be kidding me.

[Exalt]

Halp/Mleo are still the best options here. Not sure why nobody wants to move there.

[Exalt]

Willby(3) - kassius, beast, m_leon
M_leon(2) - scarlet, field
Halp(2) - voth, exalt
Field(2) - jessup, vehicle
Beast(1) - halp
PartyFalcon(1) - zeebu

No vote: PartyFalcon

[Jessup]

Oh wow, pardon me, I said Town Asshole instead of Prison Asshole.

Voth and Field low-key trying to start a bandwagon on me because I said "town" instead of "prison" coupled with the fact that the only reason we're not voting Field is because Voth came out of the woodwork to declare him innocent. Their shade towards me is the flimsiest reasoning in this thread and I can already see around the bend to what they're trying to cook up.

It's a big move because it means you're both dead when Field flips scum, but I now believe it.

Unvote WIllby
Vote Field

You guys gotta be kidding me.

:laugh: ya was weak.. plus I literally started that whole thing post one with my " Hi ummmm town " post so unsure why that is now being used as a gotcha moment on you. It was literally my whole point of making that D1 post to prove I was town. That was weak as fuck as a reason to throw a vote of u lol..

[Exalt]

Anyone else notice Halp showed up only to post because he was being brought up as a lynch candidate, yet his vote remains uselessly on Beast, he has done absolutely nothing all game, and nobody seems to want to vote him.

[Jessup]

Anyone else notice Halp showed up only to post because he was being brought up as a lynch candidate, yet his vote remains uselessly on Beast, he has done absolutely nothing all game, and nobody seems to want to vote him.

exalt why dont u consider PF too in the lurker vote ideas? PF is useless so far

[Voth]

Oh wow, pardon me, I said Town Asshole instead of Prison Asshole.

Voth and Field low-key trying to start a bandwagon on me because I said "town" instead of "prison" coupled with the fact that the only reason we're not voting Field is because Voth came out of the woodwork to declare him innocent. Their shade towards me is the flimsiest reasoning in this thread and I can already see around the bend to what they're trying to cook up.

It's a big move because it means you're both dead when Field flips scum, but I now believe it.

Unvote WIllby
Vote Field

You guys gotta be kidding me.

Unvote Halp
Vote Vehicle

If you are town, this is an easy one. Guy is caught scum. 100% - take it to the fucking bank.

Switch up to this asshole now please townies.