Forum Mafia - Shawshank Redemption - Salvation lies within

[field]

Eh? I didn't know Halp's affiliation, I was wanting to lynch Willby at the time who came off very interrogative and was seemed like he was trying to discredit me for little reason.

If I was scum I'd have jumped on Halp yesterday or today to gain some obvious townie cred, especially with so many others jumping on it. Voth called it plainly enough, it came down to who you believed, either Halp was telling the truth or lying. I incorrectly judged the former and that's where I voted.

Didn't really have a play to make, and my vote was looking like not mattering, and it didn't. I'll admit I'm now feeling a bit lost in this game, do we lynch the lurkers next or am I scum for suggesting that now? I'll agree that PF and Leo are offering nothing. But then what do we gain from their deaths, I don't know.

One possibility is that all the inactives are scum, and it's just one giant game of brinkmanship between all townies while the inactives look on. I'm really unsure what to do now if I live till tomorrow.

I never claimed to be some kind of prodigy or Einstein at this game, I don't appreciate the abuse that's been levelled against me for trying to play this game amongst some of you who've clearly been playing a lot longer, and know each other.

You gain a victory from lynching PF and m_leo.
Mark my words, they're both scum. Pretty sure Beast is too.

Don't kill a townie with your random role plz.

[field]

I said earlier in the day phase that analyzing why no NK happened last night is useless.

It still is. Let's keep scum in the dark :-)

[Beast]

Target the scum m_leo/PF/Beast. If you draw a kill, at least you'd be killing one of them not a townie.

Your role is a negative utility role. If i had it and it wasn't x-shot, I probably wouldn't use on random people.

?...

[Kassius]

Eh? I didn't know Halp's affiliation, I was wanting to lynch Willby at the time who came off very interrogative and was seemed like he was trying to discredit me for little reason.

If I was scum I'd have jumped on Halp yesterday or today to gain some obvious townie cred, especially with so many others jumping on it. Voth called it plainly enough, it came down to who you believed, either Halp was telling the truth or lying. I incorrectly judged the former and that's where I voted.

Didn't really have a play to make, and my vote was looking like not mattering, and it didn't. I'll admit I'm now feeling a bit lost in this game, do we lynch the lurkers next or am I scum for suggesting that now? I'll agree that PF and Leo are offering nothing. But then what do we gain from their deaths, I don't know.

One possibility is that all the inactives are scum, and it's just one giant game of brinkmanship between all townies while the inactives look on. I'm really unsure what to do now if I live till tomorrow.

I never claimed to be some kind of prodigy or Einstein at this game, I don't appreciate the abuse that's been levelled against me for trying to play this game amongst some of you who've clearly been playing a lot longer, and know each other.

[Exalt]

Are you forgetting the course of events that lead to the Vehicle lynch? Voth pointed it out, and I asked you directly, 'shall I vote Vehicle then?', you said yes, and then I did. I was literally the first to move off the Willby train, and Scarlet called it, 'there's our swing' or words to that effect. What did I have to gain as scum by doing what I did?

Because you refused to move to Halp along with everyone else (which is why I'm not using it as a reason for anything) and Vehicle was the only compromise we could get through.

Also, what wouldn't scum have to gain by lynching town over their strongman? Kinda common sense I think?

[Kassius]

I've been saying it all game too, as did Scarlet. All 3 of us moved to Vehicle only because nobody else would move off WillBy unless it was onto Vehicle.

Are you forgetting the course of events that lead to the Vehicle lynch? Voth pointed it out, and I asked you directly, 'shall I vote Vehicle then?', you said yes, and then I did. I was literally the first to move off the Willby train, and Scarlet called it, 'there's our swing' or words to that effect. What did I have to gain as scum by doing what I did?

[field]

An unexplained failure* sorry was driving.

[Jessup]

Dear scum I will not be using my doctor role tonight so feel free to target ANY threat you desire. This is NOT a ploy. GL mafia team..

[Exalt]

Anyway, next target should be PF. After that, I'd say Mleo probably. If that doesn't end the game, Kassius/Jessup/Beast need looking into, especially Kassius. I'd say Jessup top, but since Halp flipped strongman, there needs to be a doctor type role for that to matter, right? The Solitary action left me untargetable, so the strongman wouldn't work I think for that. Kassius on the other hand is acting weird and wont drop the tunneling and conf bias act. Seems a bit contrived at this point. Beast is just Beast, and I dont see anything overly scummy about him compared to town Beast play, but who knows. Maybe being partnered with Beast and a bunch of lurkers would drive him to be so angry all the time lol.

[Exalt]

To be completely honest though, Halp is like the worst scum player I've seen in a while. That or he doesn't care. He's been pegged as 100% scum in my mind for like 40 fucking pages and people didn't listen last phase.

You know that feeling when you push to lynch someone hard as hell and reallllly hope you don't have egg on your face after the flip because they are town? Yeah, I never even had a momentary thought like that with Halp. He was so obvious that it was brutal and bordering on disrespectful to townies with a brain.

I've been saying it all game too, as did Scarlet. All 3 of us moved to Vehicle only because nobody else would move off WillBy unless it was onto Vehicle.

[Exalt]

But now I need to hold onto it, in hopes that kassius loses his vote.

In other news, who can explain why we went at least 1 night with a mafia strongman, but no kills? I can buy that he targeted paul N1, but short of not submitting a night action, we should have another dead townie?

Well, I put myself in solitary last night, and that made me completely untargetable. Kassius claims he put Scarlet in solitary too, so that's another possibility.

[Voth]

To be completely honest though, Halp is like the worst scum player I've seen in a while. That or he doesn't care. He's been pegged as 100% scum in my mind for like 40 fucking pages and people didn't listen last phase.

You know that feeling when you push to lynch someone hard as hell and reallllly hope you don't have egg on your face after the flip because they are town? Yeah, I never even had a momentary thought like that with Halp. He was so obvious that it was brutal and bordering on disrespectful to townies with a brain.

[WillBy]

I dunno why but I thought we had 24hrs more.
Worked out fine I guess, still silence from mleo/PF
Depending on who shows up we might get inactive kills on beast/PF/leo
PPE:
I dunno why everyone expects kassius to roll a kill. The only player that's died in a night phase was the cult recruiter N1 and I've never seen anyone anywhere who thought that the factional scumkill was something which a role which copies player abilities would copy.
On reflection, willby was incidentally correct to start burning his ability to get it out of the wildcard pool, assuming kassius is legit.

But now I need to hold onto it, in hopes that kassius loses his vote.

In other news, who can explain why we went at least 1 night with a mafia strongman, but no kills? I can buy that he targeted paul N1, but short of not submitting a night action, we should have another dead townie?

[Exalt]

This shit is actually pissing me off. Your lack of ability to read posts doesn’t make me a fucking lurker. What has anyone “done”??? I have my opinions D1, I thought Willby was being weird and I didn’t believe Jessups doctor claim. I posted that, but now I’m under fire for not giving Jessup a fucking gun? I opposed the vehicle lynch and felt it was a scummy bandwagon, I voiced that opinion. Most of the people on the two town wagons are also on my scum list, and have continued to attack me for reasons that don’t make sense. I used my investigative action because I had a strong scum read. Exalt, king of the fucking townies, can you explain why Voth had a fun last night if he used up his cop ability N1? Would a librarian typically have a gun?

I post my opinions, I play to my win condition, and I use my action on people that I consider a threat to it. I would argue that YOU’RE fucking useless. So far you’ve lynched two townies, what else have you “done”? I would have you on my scum list if I could wrap my head around the idea of a D1 governor fakeclaim. Then again you haven’t proven it, and now it sounds like maybe it’s xshot so maybe you never will.

Sit in spec. Ez

[Voth]

No everyone, please take it easy on Jessup. I'm clearly scum. Field too. It's so obvious that it's obvious, right?