Forum Mafia - Shawshank Redemption - Salvation lies within

[Jessup]

Do you have any thoughts on leo or beast?

Leo was after field which I liked, beast is seeming brash but town. ZERO verifiable way this phase to know any real info going for either m_leo or beast but.... if we go for field we can either get a full claim from field or lynch him and see how he flips and at the same time learn the truth about if Voth is scum. Field is a 2 for one deal including that also includes voth being outted. Voth has by far been the most destructive player for town. He has a proven record of complete anti town moves.. that D1 nonsense train outting doctor and being the deciding vote to kill sherlock over soe bs at that too.. sherlock was not scummy seeming to me at all yet voth said he was like a fool and now we have this d2 convenient out of the woodwork "I investigated field" claim AFTER exalt started a train on him. All seems way too convenient. Voth and field need to be pushed on HARD NOW

[Zeebu]

PartyFalcon is also a possibility who I keep forgetting about, but not someone I'd lynch right now over the other two.

for hte time being i buy vehicles claim so hes off the list.

i'll go read through willby's claim again and think on how palatable it is

why not PF though?

[Zeebu]

bah, wrote that before you responded. stupid forums

[Zeebu]

WillBy Vehicle

I have one angle left though that nobody has discussed. If we assume that Paul tried to recruit scum, which is my take on things, then who would he have tried to recruit? This is a meta thing to answer, but it's worth looking at.

When I looked at the likely players who could be scum and who Paul would've tried to recruit. I find it extremely unlikely for Beast to ever be recruited by Paul. Ditto for MLeo. Halp is possible, but doubtful. I thought Field was a definite possibility, but Voth got the inno result on him. That doesn't mean Field can't be a Godfather, but it's not worth pursuing unless all other options exhaust themselves first. Zeebu was unlikely imo, but he wouldn't be a terrible option. His neighbor note thing takes that away though imo, since i dont know why that would be a scum role. That leave both WillBy and Vehicleas the most logical options left.

I mean, other than that, there's me, Scarlet, and Voth, but since I don't think it likely that Voth is scum, and I know I'm town (plus I usually die early in these games as town), that leaves only Scarlet. I'm going to guess that Paul didn't try to recruit them on his first try. Scarlet seems like someone you'd recruit later in the game.

Since I don't think you two are bussing each other, what do you think of the other one possibly having been the scum player Paul targetted? I mean, maybe Paul was a scum kill, but that doesn't really make sense, considering most Cult Recruiters have BP and not trying to kill the claimed town doc when the watcher just died doesn't make a ton of sense to me.

assuming paul died while trying to recruit, i think PF is an extremely viable target for him. not a big contributor this game yet but seems like a strong player based on last game. i find it somewhat suspect of you that you left him off your list.

[Exalt]

PartyFalcon is also a possibility who I keep forgetting about, but not someone I'd lynch right now over the other two.

[Zeebu]

Also I just full-claimed my role, which could potentially benefit town, unlike yours.

interesting. so unlike hider, you can go behind a mafia member and not auto-die. that is a fairly strong pro-town role imo since if you were targeted a night when you targeted (assholed?) a mafia member the mafia could conceivably put a hit on themselves. great fun.

if you asshole behind a town and that town is targeted you both die. if you asshole behind a town and youre targetted, the town dies. no bueno in either case


so your role cant really be used as investigative at all, but provided you can keep assholing suspected mafia members then its a great benefit to town.


i cannot see how this role would benefit someone mafia aligned.

unless you pulled this role out of your ass (ahahaha nailed it) i would give you a strong town lean based on that claim

[Exalt]

Also Vehicle, what do you think of Mleo and Halp being the two wagons?

[Exalt]

WillBy Vehicle

I have one angle left though that nobody has discussed. If we assume that Paul tried to recruit scum, which is my take on things, then who would he have tried to recruit? This is a meta thing to answer, but it's worth looking at.

When I looked at the likely players who could be scum and who Paul would've tried to recruit. I find it extremely unlikely for Beast to ever be recruited by Paul. Ditto for MLeo. Halp is possible, but doubtful. I thought Field was a definite possibility, but Voth got the inno result on him. That doesn't mean Field can't be a Godfather, but it's not worth pursuing unless all other options exhaust themselves first. Zeebu was unlikely imo, but he wouldn't be a terrible option. His neighbor note thing takes that away though imo, since i dont know why that would be a scum role. That leave both WillBy and Vehicleas the most logical options left.

I mean, other than that, there's me, Scarlet, and Voth, but since I don't think it likely that Voth is scum, and I know I'm town (plus I usually die early in these games as town), that leaves only Scarlet. I'm going to guess that Paul didn't try to recruit them on his first try. Scarlet seems like someone you'd recruit later in the game.

Since I don't think you two are bussing each other, what do you think of the other one possibly having been the scum player Paul targetted? I mean, maybe Paul was a scum kill, but that doesn't really make sense, considering most Cult Recruiters have BP and not trying to kill the claimed town doc when the watcher just died doesn't make a ton of sense to me.

[WillBy]

Vote Field with me any1? Going to bed but leaving my vote there since scum who are actively spinning towns wheels so we get no where today.. When/ if I see a decent train with logic behind I may switch but still feel voth is scummy as shit and field is the way to out voth once and for all..

Do you have any thoughts on leo or beast?

[WillBy]

Also I just full-claimed my role, which could potentially benefit town, unlike yours.

If you're telling the truth there, chief. You sound like a less-swingy version of a hider, which is conveniently unverifiable. Furthermore, you claimed 2-shot on it, which I cant tell if I like or not. On one hand, it prevents you from being unkillable in the endgame, but on the other hand, you can pretty much screw up protections and the like. If you had (for some reason) hid behind jessup last night, you would be dead?

im going to start calling it the bus-hider, because it's a combination of hider and busdriver. Btw your role is no longer useful to town. The only use for it is to "hide behind" scum so they kill themselves when they target you. But now that wont happen...

The thing that probably bugs me most is that you've come in all high and mighty with this claim after almost every active player has made a claim. There wasnt any new information besides "dont lynch me I'm a town". If it's real, you are no longer a night kill target, which makes you as useful but less verifiable than zeebu. You only claimed once you are sure exalt wont let you be lynched.
Suspicious.

[Jessup]

Vote Field with me any1? Going to bed but leaving my vote there since scum who are actively spinning towns wheels so we get no where today.. When/ if I see a decent train with logic behind I may switch but still feel voth is scummy as shit and field is the way to out voth once and for all..

[WillBy]

Mother fucker the reason my "votes look suspect" to you is because I've been consistently voting for your dumbass scum self.

This thread has got to be close to 30,000 words at this point, I work full-time. I'm trying my best. If this level of activity isn't enough for you, don't @ me next signup thread.

Chill. Of course your votes look suspect, you have been voting me, and I know I'm town.
You are doing fine with activity, I just said you arent too much more active. And you arent the only one working full time, I'm fairly certain theres a reason kthx phase changes at 7am and 7pm his time. I'm at work right now (slow week). You are 4th on my lynch list, though I'm really confused by your roleclaim and will need more time to digest it

[Vehicle]

Also I just full-claimed my role, which could potentially benefit town, unlike yours.

[Vehicle]

Vehicle hasnt been too much more active, his votes look suspect, and his justification for most of those isnt his own.

Mother fucker the reason my "votes look suspect" to you is because I've been consistently voting for your dumbass scum self.

This thread has got to be close to 30,000 words at this point, I work full-time. I'm trying my best. If this level of activity isn't enough for you, don't @ me next signup thread.

[WillBy]

lol I was about to ask you why you weren't voting leo
WillBy What makes you put halp over vehicle?

I've felt like Halps (admittedly brief) time in thread has had him posting honestly, asking questions. Maybe it's just him playing as scum well, but he doesnt look "in the know" to me.
Vehicle hasnt been too much more active, his votes look suspect, and his justification for most of those isnt his own.

I want to be totally clear, at some point that list of town reads changed to "order I would see people lynched", which is why some people look a bit out of order. Like scarlet is low because he hasnt claimed, but voth his below field because Voth being lynched could make field look really good.

Town: willby>zeebu>exalt
Probably town: field>voth>jessup>kassius>scarlet
unsure: halp>vehicle>partyfalcon>beast>leo

at least one in the "probably town" category is almost certainly scum. Cant tell who though. Luckily we dont need every scum pegged today. At best we can get rid of 2.